Стратегии на образователната и научната политика

https://doi.org/10.53656/str2024-5s-18-tea

2024/5s, стр. 182 - 188

TEACHERS' ADAPTATION TO CHANGES IN AN INCREASINGLY COMPLEX WORLD THROUGH THE USE OF AI

Zhanat Nurbekova
OrcID: 0000-0003-0249-7690
E-mail: nurbekova_zhk@digitalexgroup.com
Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University
13, Dostyk аve.
Almaty, Kazakhstan
Kanagat Baigusheva
Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University
Kalima Tuenbaeva
Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University
Bakyt Nurbekov
Abai Kazakh National Pedagogical University
Tsvetomir Vassilev
OrcID: 0000-0002-0067-7316
E-mail: tvassilev@uni-ruse.bg
University of Ruse “Angel Kanchev”
8, Studentska St.
7017 Ruse, Bulgaria

Резюме: In a rapidly changing world, the adaptation of educators to new challenges becomes critical. Our research within the framework of the research and technical program (grant No. BR21882260, funded by the Science Committee of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan) found that 9,890 (16.1%) of 61,426 teachers consider innovation, creativity, and critical thinking skills to be unimportant or not very important for mentoring. This rejection of an innovation requires a deep understanding of its causes and consequences. These objections may be due to fear of an uncertain future, misunderstanding of the benefits of artificial intelligence (AI), or fear of job loss. The current paper presents the conditions and mechanisms for teachers to adapt to changes in an increasingly complex world using AI.

Ключови думи: teachers' adaptation; AI in teaching; emotional AI; digital facilitator; professional network

1. Introduction

In a rapidly changing world, teachers' adaptation to new challenges becomes critical. The dynamics of development of modern technologies and innovations are the driving force behind changes in educational paradigms. Despite all the changes in the external environment and teaching tools, interaction with a qualified teacher remains a key element of an effective educational process.

Since the new generation and the modern teacher today are in the same starting position facing uncertainty, the need to adapt both sides increases in the conditions of exponential transformation of the educational eco-environment under the external influence of scientific and technological progress.

Our research has established that teachers’ perceptions of the AI phenomenon in society have different consequences. On the one hand, complete admiration for the capabilities of AI, tracking AI trends and its gradual implementation in various types of activities, and on the other hand, the emergence of various difficulties in the implementation of AI, such as preventing changes or denying opportunities as a result of its evolutionary development.

Note that 9,890 (16.1%) of 61,426 teachers believe that innovation, creativity and critical thinking skills are not important, or are not particularly important for mentoring. This rejection of an innovation requires a deep understanding of its causes and consequences.

These objections challenge educational science and test a number of assumptions: opposition to innovation may be driven by fear of an uncertain future, misunderstanding of the benefits of AI, or fear of job loss. To overcome these challenges, research is also required on the conditions and mechanisms for teachers to adapt to changes in an increasingly complex world through the use of AI.

The rest of the paper is organized as follows. The next section reviews some existing technologies for applying AI in education. Section 3 presents our research survey and results and the last section concludes the paper.

2. Review of AI educational technologies

A review and analysis of AI technologies in education and modern pedagogical methodologies within the framework of the Bett Show 2020–2023, FETC-2024, and the global intelligent data platform HolonIQ showed that today AI assists the teacher not only as a smart tool to support the teachers' professional activities, but also as a multimodal agent of all their activities throughout the educational process. There are ideas of considering the usage of AI in education as an integral part of determining the degree of digitalization of a higher education institution (Beloev et al. 2023).

Research and scientific publications note that emotional AI is able to “identify, understand and respond to human emotions” (Muskan & Deepika 2023). In addition the Quantum Learning educational methodology (Li et al 2020) triggers the brain’s natural ways of learning to maximize learner engagement, understanding, competence, reflection and self-esteem. At the same time, quantum learning is considered as a process that includes uncertainty and openness to new opportunities and paths of development (Syukria 2019).

Taking into account the above, we can conclude that a change in the paradigm of education in an increasingly complex world requires the implementation of pedagogical centering in the professional development of a teacher. In this regard, it is necessary to consider the conditions and mechanisms of adaptation to new realities through personal changes in the teacher, social support and interaction between teachers. One of the effective approaches to adapting teachers to changes will be the creation of a supportive community – a professional network of facilitators through the use of AI.

The importance of teaching communities and their facilitators for teacher professional development has been noted by various researchers like Perry & Boylan 2017, Vangrieken, Meredith, Packer & Kyndt 2017, Aangenendt, Sjoer & Wallner 2023. Summarizing a series of studies (Perry & Boylan 2017; Perry & Bevins 2019; Perry & Boodt 2019) in her work Emily Perry defines three roles of those who contribute to the professional development of teachers: coordinators, designers and facilitators (Perry 2020).

3. Research study and results

As part of the implementation of the research and technical program: “Creating a system of continuous professional development of teachers in the aspect of education for a complex world: paradigm, methodology, digital tools” (BR 21882260) (2023 – 2025) with the participation of the National Center for Advanced Training “Orleu” in February 2024, a survey of teachers of the Republic of Kazakhstan was conducted to study the needs of general secondary school teachers in a professional network of facilitators. The survey involved 61,426 teachers of general secondary schools, including 85% women and 15% men.

The number of teachers with teaching and scientific-pedagogical experience of less than 5 years was 17%, from 5 to 9 years 16%, from 10 to 14 years 16%, from 15 to 19 years 14%, from 20 to 24 years 12%, from 25 up to 29 years old 10% and over 30 years old 15%. Thus, more than half of the respondents (67%) have more than 10 years of work experience.

The survey among teachers of secondary schools in Kazakhstan showed that teachers in their continuous professional development could rely on the help of facilitators. Thus, 73.26% of respondents agreed with the statement “A teacher can develop professionally in interaction with the professional community,” which confirms the relevance of professional communities of teachers. 31% of teachers noted that they quite often receive professional support from a mentor.

Figure 1. Respondents’ answers to the question “How often would you need the help of a facilitator (mentor) in your professional development”

Systematic support is provided to young specialists; 80.2% of teachers with up to 5 years of experience interact on an ongoing basis with a colleague whom they consider their pedagogical mentor. However, the majority of those with more than 5 years of work experience do not have their own officially assigned mentor (77.5%).

75% of teachers noted that they need support from a facilitator (mentor) with a certain frequency, among them 68% of teachers need support annually or more often than once a year (Figure 1).

Figure 2. A diagram of interaction between a teacher and real and digital facilitators

Teachers noted thematic seminars and sessions, individual and group meetings as the most preferred formats of interaction with facilitators.

56.6% of respondents would like to gain experience as a mentor themselves. Teachers noted the most important competencies of the facilitator: knowledge of the subject area, deep knowledge of pedagogical content, creativity, critical thinking, constant improvement of their own professional qualifications.

Thus, creating a professional network of facilitators for continuous professional development of teachers can provide professional, methodological and emotional support to teachers, helping and inspiring them. In this way it will also help to improve the quality of teaching and relationships with students, the development of creativity and motivation for professional development.

The architecture of the professional network of facilitators should provide for interaction with both a “live facilitator” and a “digital facilitator”, providing augmented reality to the teacher. The digital facilitator implements basic facilitation techniques, for example, Me We Us, which allows the opinion of each participant (teacher and live facilitator) to be taken into account. At the same time, the logical structure of the interaction of a real facilitator in the network is reinforced by the multimodal agency of the “digital facilitator”. Such a model of interaction in a professional network of facilitators will make it possible to comprehensively provide for unstable conditions and cover all possible adaptation mechanisms for a teacher (see Figure 2 and Figure 3). The key characteristic of such a network is the pedagogical focus of the organization of continuous professional development of the teacher.

Figure 3. Architecture of a professional network of facilitators

The key adaptation mechanisms for teachers to be implemented in this professional network are:

1. Regular professional development through courses on new teaching methods, technologies and changes in curriculum.

2. Integration of digital tools and educational platforms for the learning process.

3. Cooperation with colleagues, exchange of experience to develop new learning strategies, mutual support and motivation.

4. Using emotional artificial intelligence, work on your emotional and psychological state to maintain energy levels and motivation.

5. Experiment with everything new and adapt them to changes in the educational eco-environment.

The above mechanisms allow teachers to cope with the challenges of uncertainty, as well as constantly develop in the professional field.

4. Conclusion

In the era of digitalization of all spheres of modern society, digital support is needed to create a permanent professional network of facilitators for teachers. Therefore, the capabilities of AI, such as emotional AI and the methodology of quantum pedagogy, at the core of the digital ecosystem will ensure the interaction of facilitators (real and digital) and teachers in the network, expand opportunities and create conditions for the continuous professional development of teachers.

Acknowledgments & Funding

This study is financed by the European Union – NextGenerationEU, through the National Recovery and Resilience Plan of the Republic of Bulgaria, project № BG-RRP-2.013-0001-C01.

REFERENCES

BELOEV, H., SMRIKAROV, A., VOINOHOVSKA, V., & IVANOVA, G., 2023. Determining the degree of digitalization of a higher education institution. Strategies for Policy in Science & Education-Strategii na Obrazovatelnata i Nauchnata Politika, vol. 31, no. 4s, pp.9 – 21. https://doi.org/10.53656/str2023-4s-1-det.

MUSKAN G., DEEPIKAK, 2023. Emotional AI and Human-AI Interactions in Social Networking, eBook ISBN: 9780443190971.

LI, Y.; TIAN, M.; LIU, G.; PENG, C. & JIAO, L., 2020. Quantum Optimization and Quantum Learning: A Survey. IEEE Access, vol. 8, pp. 23568 – 23593, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2020.2970105.

SYUKRIA, Z, 2019. The Effectiveness of Quantum Learning Method to Students’ English Learning Achievement at SMK N 9 Padang. Jurnal Ilmiah Universitas Batanghari Jambi. 19. 229. 10.33087/jiubj.v19i2.618.

PERRY, E. & BOYLAN, M., 2017. Developing the developers: supporting and researching the learning of professional development facilitators. Professional development in education, vol. 44, no. 2, pp. 254 – 271. DOI: 10.1080/19415257.2017.1287767.

AANGENENDT, M.; SJOER E. & Wallner C., 2023. Facilitation of Value Creation in Professional Learning Networks. Higher Education Studies, vol. 13, no. 3. DOI:10.5539/hes.v13n3p31

VANGRIEKEN K.; MEREDITH C.; PACKER T. & KYNDT E., 2017. Teacher communities as a context for professional development: A systematic review. Teaching and Teacher Education: An International Journal of Research and Studies, vol. 61, no. 1, pp. 47 – 59. Elsevier Ltd. Retrieved April 15, 2024 from https://www.learntechlib.org/p/202127/.

PERRY E., & BEVINS S., 2019. Building capacity for professional development: the development of teachers as facilitators in Ghana. Professional Development in Education, vol. 45, no. 3, pp. 390 – 404. https://doi.org/10.1080/19415257.2018.1474489.

PERRY E. & BOODT S., 2019. Supporting the Professional Development of' Hybrid'Teacher Educators in the Further Education Sector. Teacher Education Advancement Network Journal, vol. 11, no. 3 pp. 60 – 71.

PERRY E., 2020. The roles of professional development leaders. Science Teacher Education no. 88, pp.10 – 16. https://shura.shu.ac.uk/id/ eprint/27337.

2025 година
Книжка 6
UNLOCKING THE POTENTIAL OF ESG AND AI IN HIGHER EDUCATION FINANCE: INSIGHTS FROM A STUDY ACROSS FIVE EUROPEAN COUNTRIES

Tina Vukasović, Rok Strašek, Liliya Terzieva;, Elenita Velikova, Justyna Tomala, Maria Urbaniec, Jarosław Pawlik, Michael Murg, Anita Maček

THE ROLE OF HIGHER EDUCATION FOR THE PROFESSIONAL REALIZATION OF STUDENTS – PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS

Anny Atanasova, Viktoriya Kalaydzhieva, Radostina Yuleva-Chuchulayna, Kalina Durova-Angelova

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
ТРАНСФОРМАЦИИ НА ПАЗАРА НА ТРУДА И НУЖДАТА ОТ ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛНИ РЕФОРМИ

Ваня Иванова, Андрей Василев, Калоян Ганев, Ралица Симеонова-Ганева

Книжка 3
FORMING ENTREPRENEURIAL CULTURE THROUGH EDUCATION

Milena Filipova, Adriana Atanasova

Книжка 2s
THE STATE OF INCLUSION IN ADAPTED BASKETBALL

Stefka Djobova, Ivelina Kirilova

Книжка 2
MODEL OF PROFESSIONALLY DIRECTED TRAINING OF FUTURE ENGINEER-TEACHERS

Ivan Beloev, Valentina Vasileva, Іnna Savytska, Oksana Bulgakova, Lesia Zbaravska, Olha Chaikovska

DETERMINANTS AFFECTING ACADEMIC STAFF SATISFACTION WITH ONLINE LEARNING IN HIGHER MEDICAL EDUCATION

Miglena Tarnovska, ;, Rumyana Stoyanova, ;, Angelina Kirkova-Bogdanova;, Rositsa Dimova

Книжка 1s
AN INNOVATIVE MODEL FOR DEVELOPING DIGITAL COMPETENCES OF SOCIAL WORKERS

Lyudmila Vekova, Tanya Vazova, Penyo Georgiev, Ekaterina Uzhikanova-Kovacheva

Книжка 1
2024 година
Книжка 6s
DISRUPTIVE TECHNOLOGIES RISK MANAGEMENT

Miglena Molhova-Vladova, Ivaylo B. Ivanov

Книжка 6
AN INTEGRATIVE APPROACH TO ORGANIZING THE FORMATION OF STUDENTS’ COGNITIVE INDEPENDENCE IN CONDITIONS OF INTENSIFICATION OF LEARNING ACTIVITIES

Albina Volkotrubova, Aidai Kasymova, Zoriana Hbur, Antonina Kichuk, Svitlana Koshova, Svitlana Khodakivska

ИНОВАТИВЕН МОДЕЛ НА ПРОЕКТНО БАЗИРАНО ОБУЧЕНИЕ НА ГИМНАЗИАЛНИ УЧИТЕЛИ: ДОБРА ПРАКТИКА ОТ УниБИТ

Жоржета Назърска, Александър Каракачанов, Магдалена Гарванова, Нина Дебрюне

Книжка 5s
КОНЦЕПТУАЛНА РАМКА ЗА ИЗПОЛЗВАНЕ НА ИЗКУСТВЕНИЯ ИНТЕЛЕКТ ВЪВ ВИСШЕТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Акад. Христо Белоев, Валентина Войноховска, Ангел Смрикаров

ИЗСЛЕДВАНЕ ПРИЛОЖИМОСТТА НА БЛОКОВИ ВЕРИГИ ОТ ПЪРВО НИВО (L1) В СИСТЕМА ЗА ЕЛЕКТРОННО ОБУЧЕНИЕ

Андриан Минчев, Ваня Стойкова, Галя Шивачева, Доц Анелия Иванова

ПРЕДИЗВИКАТЕЛСТВА ПРИ ПРОМЯНА НА ПЛАТФОРМИ ЗА ДИСТАНЦИОННО ОБУЧЕНИЕ

Антон Недялков, Милена Кирова, Мирослава Бонева

APPLICATION OF ZSPACE TECHNOLOGY IN THE DISCIPLINES OF THE STEM CYCLE

Boyana Ivanova, Kamelia Shoilekova, Desislava Atanasova, Rumen Rusev

TEACHERS' ADAPTATION TO CHANGES IN AN INCREASINGLY COMPLEX WORLD THROUGH THE USE OF AI

Zhanat Nurbekova, Kanagat Baigusheva, Kalima Tuenbaeva, Bakyt Nurbekov, Tsvetomir Vassilev

АТОСЕКУНДНОТО ОБУЧЕНИЕ – МЕТАФОРА НА ДНЕШНОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Юлия Дончева, Денис Асенов, Ангел Смрикаров, Цветомир Василев

Книжка 5
Книжка 4s
Книжка 4
MANAGERIAL ASPECTS OF COOPERATION AMONG HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS AND THEIR STAKEHOLDERS

Olha Prokopenko, Svitlana Perova, Tokhir Rakhimov, Mykola Kunytskyi, Iryna Leshchenko

Книжка 3s
Книжка 3
Книжка 2
FORMATION OF PROFESSIONAL SKILLS OF AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERS DURING LABORATORY PRACTICE WHEN STUDYING FUNDAMENTAL SCIENCE

Ivan Beloev, Oksana Bulgakova, Oksana Zakhutska, Maria Bondar, Lesia Zbaravska

ИМИДЖ НА УНИВЕРСИТЕТА

Галя Христозова

Книжка 1s
COMPETITIVENESS AS A RESULT OF CREATIVITY AND INNOVATION

Nikolay Krushkov, Ralitza Zayakova-Krushkova

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND SECURITY IN THE INTEGRATED CIRCUITS INDUSTRY

Ivan Nachev, Yuliana Tomova, Iskren Konstantinov, Marina Spasova

Книжка 1
PROBLEMS AND PERSPECTIVES FOR SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN HIGHER EDUCATION

Milena Filipova, Olha Prokopenko, Igor Matyushenko, Olena Khanova, Olga Shirobokova, Ardian Durmishi

2023 година
Книжка 6s
DEVELOPMENT OF A COMMON INFORMATION SYSTEM TO CREATE A DIGITAL CAREER CENTER TOGETHER WITH PARTNER HIGHER SCHOOLS

Yordanka Angelova, Rossen Radonov, Vasil Kuzmov, Stela Zhorzh Derelieva-Konstantinova

DRAFTING A DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION STRATEGY FOR PROJECT MANAGEMENT SECTOR – EMPIRICAL STUDY ON UAE

Mounir el Khatib, Shikha al Ali, Ibrahim Alharam, Ali Alhajeri, Gabriela Peneva, Jordanka Angelova, Mahmoud Shanaa

VOYAGE OF LEARNING: CRUISE SHIPS WEATHER ROUTING AND MARITIME EDUCATION

Svetlana Dimitrakieva, Dobrin Milev, Christiana Atanasova

СТРУКТУРНИ ПРОМЕНИ В ОБУЧЕНИЕТО НА МЕНИДЖЪРИ ЗА ИНДУСТРИЯ 5.0

Недко Минчев, Венета Христова, Иван Стоянов

RESEARCH OF THE INNOVATION CAPACITY OF AGRICULTURAL PRODUCERS

Siya Veleva, ; Margarita Mondeshka, Anka Tsvetanova

Книжка 6
Книжка 5s
ВИДОВЕ ТРАВМИ В ПАРАШУТИЗМА И ПРЕВЕНЦИЯТА ИМ

Капитан III ранг Георги Калинов

Книжка 5
Книжка 4s
DETERMINING THE DEGREE OF DIGITALIZATION OF A HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTION

Acad. Hristo Beloev, Angel Smrikarov, Valentina Voinohovska, Galina Ivanova

ОТ STEM КЪМ BEST: ДВА СТАНДАРТА, ЕДНА ЦЕЛ

Андрей Захариев, Стефан Симеонов, Таня Тодорова

Книжка 4
EFFECT OF RESILIENCE ON BURNOUT IN ONLINE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT

Radina Stoyanova, Sonya Karabeliova, Petya Pandurova, Nadezhda Zheckova, Kaloyan Mitev

Книжка 3s
INTELLIGENT ANIMAL HUSBANDRY: FARMER ATTITUDES AND A ROADMAP FOR IMPLEMENTATION

Dimitrios Petropoulos, Koutroubis Fotios, Petya Biolcheva, Evgeni Valchev

Книжка 3
STUDY OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE USE OF COMMUNICATIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE EDUCATIONAL PROCESS OF ENGINEERS TRAINING

Ivan Beloev, Valentina Vasileva, Sergii Bilan, Maria Bondar, Oksana Bulgakova, Lyubov Shymko

Книжка 2
РАЗПОЛОЖЕНИЕ НА ВИСШИТЕ УЧИЛИЩА В БЪЛГАРИЯ В КОНТЕКСТА НА ФОРМИРАНЕ НА ПАЗАРА НА ТРУДА

Цветелина Берберова-Вълчева, Камен Петров, Николай Цонков

Книжка 1
MODERNIZATION OF THE CONTENT OF THE LECTURE COURSE IN PHYSICS FOR TRAINING FUTURE AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERS

Ivan Beloev, Valentina Vasileva, Vasyl Shynkaruk, Oksana Bulgakova, Maria Bondar, Lesia Zbaravska, Sergii Slobodian

2022 година
Книжка 6
ORGANIZATION OF AN INCLUSIVE EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT FOR THE STUDENTS WITH SPECIAL NEEDS

Halyna Bilavych, Nataliia Bakhmat, Tetyana Pantiuk, Mykola Pantiuk, Borys Savchuk

ДИГИТАЛИЗАЦИЯ НА ОБРАЗОВАНИЕТО В БЪЛГАРИЯ: СЪСТОЯНИЕ И ОБЩИ ТЕНДЕНЦИИ

Теодора Върбанова, Албена Вуцова, Николай Нетов

Книжка 5
ПРАВОТО НА ИЗБОР В ЖИВОТА НА ДЕЦАТА В РЕПУБЛИКА БЪЛГАРИЯ

Сийка Чавдарова-Костова, Даниела Рачева, Екатерина Томова, Росица Симеонова

Книжка 4
DIAGNOSIS AS A TOOL FOR MONITORING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF ADDICTION PREVENTION IN ADOLESCENTS

O.A. Selivanova, N.V. Bystrova, I.I. Derecha, T.S. Mamontova, O.V. Panfilova

Книжка 3
ПУБЛИЧНОТО РАЗБИРАНЕ НА НАУКАТА В МРЕЖОВИЯ СВЯТ

Светломир Здравков, Мартин Й. Иванов, Петя Климентова

Книжка 2
Книжка 1
ДИГИТАЛНАТА ИНТЕРАКЦИЯ ПРЕПОДАВАТЕЛ – СТУДЕНТ В ОНЛАЙН ОБУЧЕНИЕТО В МЕДИЦИНСКИТЕ УНИВЕРСИТЕТИ

Миглена Търновска, Румяна Стоянова, Боряна Парашкевова, Юлияна Маринова

2021 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4s
SIGNAL FOR HELP

Ina Vladova, Milena Kuleva

Книжка 4
PREMISES FOR A MULTICULTURAL APPROACH TO EDUCATION

Anzhelina Koriakina, Lyudmila Amanbaeva

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
ПЪРВА СЕДМИЦА ДИСТАНЦИОННО ОБУЧЕНИЕ В СУ „ИВАН ВАЗОВ“ В СТАРА ЗАГОРА

Тони Чехларова, Динко Цвятков, Неда Чехларова

Книжка 1
METHODOLOGY OF SAFETY AND QUALITY OF LIFE ON THE BASIS OF NOOSPHERIC EDUCATION SYSTEM FORMATION

Nataliia Bakhmat, Nataliia Ridei, Nataliia Tytova, Vladyslava Liubarets, Oksana Katsero

2020 година
Книжка 6
HIGHER EDUCATION AS A PUBLIC GOOD

Yulia Nedelcheva, Miroslav Nedelchev

Книжка 5
НАСЪРЧАВАНЕ НА СЪТРУДНИЧЕСТВОТО МЕЖДУ ВИСШИТЕ УЧИЛИЩА И БИЗНЕСА

Добринка Стоянова, Блага Маджурова, Гергана Димитрова, Стефан Райчев

Книжка 4
THE STRATEGY OF HUMAN RIGHTS STUDY IN EDUCATION

Anush Balian, Nataliya Seysebayeva, Natalia Efremova, Liliia Danylchenko

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
МИГРАЦИЯ И МИГРАЦИОННИ ПРОЦЕСИ

Веселина Р. Иванова

SOCIAL STATUS OF DISABLED PEOPLE IN RUSSIA

Elena G. Pankova, Tatiana V. Soloveva, Dinara A. Bistyaykina, Olga M. Lizina

Книжка 1
ETHNIC UPBRINGING AS A PART OF THE ETHNIC CULTURE

Sholpankulova Gulnar Kenesbekovna

2019 година
Книжка 6
EMOTIONAL COMPETENCE OF THE SOCIAL TEACHER

Kadisha K. Shalgynbayeva, Ulbosin Zh.Tuyakova

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
УЧИЛИЩЕТО НА БЪДЕЩЕТО

Наталия Витанова

Книжка 2
Книжка 1
POST-GRADUATE QUALIFICATION OF TEACHERS IN INTERCULTURAL EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT

Irina Koleva, Veselin Tepavicharov, Violeta Kotseva, Kremena Yordanova

ДЕЦАТА В КОНСТИТУЦИОННИТЕ НОРМИ НА БЪЛГАРИЯ

Румен Василев, Весела Марева

СЪСТОЯНИЕ НА БЪЛГАРСКОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Анелия Любенова, Любомир Любенов

ЕДИН НОВ УЧЕБНИК

Ирина Колева

2018 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
A NEW AWARD FOR PROFESSOR MAIRA KABAKOVA

Irina Koleva, Editor-in-

Книжка 4
Книжка 3
BLENDED EDUCATION IN HIGHER SCHOOLS: NEW NETWORKS AND MEDIATORS

Nikolay Tsankov, Veska Gyuviyska, Milena Levunlieva

ВЗАИМОВРЪЗКАТА МЕЖДУ СПОРТА И ПРАВОТО

Ивайло Прокопов, Елица Стоянова

ХИМЕРНИТЕ ГРУПИ В УЧИЛИЩЕ

Яна Рашева-Мерджанова

Книжка 2
Книжка 1
2017 година
Книжка 6
ЗНАЧИМОСТТА НА УЧЕНЕТО: АНАЛИЗ НА ВРЪЗКИТЕ МЕЖДУ ГЛЕДНИТЕ ТОЧКИ НА УЧЕНИЦИ, РОДИТЕЛИ И УЧИТЕЛИ

Илиана Мирчева, Елена Джамбазова, Снежана Радева, Деян Велковски

Книжка 5
ОРГАНИЗАЦИОННА КУЛТУРА В УЧИЛИЩЕ

Ивайло Старибратов, Лилия Бабакова

Книжка 4
КОУЧИНГ. ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЕН КОУЧИНГ

Наталия Витанова, Нели Митева

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
Книжка 1
ЕМПАТИЯ И РЕФЛЕКСИЯ

Нели Кънева, Кристиана Булдеева

2016 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
Книжка 2
Книжка 1
2015 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4
ПРАГМАТИЧНАТА ДИДАКТИКА

Николай Колишев

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
Книжка 1
2014 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
КОХЕРЕНТНОСТ НА ПОЛИТИКИ

Албена Вуцова, Лиляна Павлова

Книжка 4
USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

Книжка 3
USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

Книжка 2
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT OF UNIVERSITY FACULTY: А SOCIOLOGICAL ANALYSIS

Gulnar Toltaevna Balakayeva, Alken Shugaybekovich Tokmagambetov, Sapar Imangalievich Ospanov

USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

Книжка 1
РЕФЛЕКСИЯТА В ИНТЕГРАТИВНОТО ПОЛЕ НА МЕТОДИКАТА НА ОБУЧЕНИЕТО ПО БИОЛОГИЯ

Иса Хаджиали, Наташа Цанова, Надежда Райчева, Снежана Томова

USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

2013 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4
QUESTIONNAIRE DEVELOPMENT

ÎÖÅÍßÂÀÍÅÒÎ

Книжка 3
MASS MEDIA CULTURE IN KAZAKHSTAN

Aktolkyn Kulsariyeva Yerkin Massanov Indira Alibayeva

РЪКОВОДСТВО ЗА СЪСТАВЯНЕ НА ТЕСТОВЕ*

Фернандо Картрайт, Джери Мусио

РОССИЙСКАЯ СИСТЕМА ОЦЕНКИ КАЧЕСТВА ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ: ГЛАВНЫЕ УРОКИ

В. Болотов / И. Вальдман / Г. Ковалёва / М. Пинская

Книжка 2
ОЦЕНЯВАНЕ НА ГРАЖДАНСКИТЕ КОМПЕТЕНТНОСТИ НА УЧЕНИЦИТЕ: ПРЕДИЗВИКАТЕЛСТВА И ВЪЗМОЖНОСТИ

Светла Петрова Център за контрол и оценка на качеството на училищното образование

РЪКОВОДСТВО ЗА СЪСТАВЯНЕ НА ТЕСТОВЕ*

Фернандо Картрайт, Джери Мусио

Книжка 1
Уважаеми читатели,

вет, както и от международния борд за предоставените статии и студии, за да могат да бъдат идентифицирани в полето на образованието пред широката аудитория от педа- гогически специалисти във всички степени на образователната ни система. Благодаря за техния всеотдаен и безвъзмезден труд да създават и популяризират мрежа от научни съобщества по профила на списанието и да насърчават научните изследвания. Благодаря на рецензентите от национално представените висши училища, на- учни институции и

РЪКОВОДСТВО ЗА СЪСТАВЯНЕ НА ТЕСТОВЕ

Фернандо Картрайт, Джери Мусио

2012 година
Книжка 6
DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENCE IN KAZAKHSTAN IN THE PERIOD OF INDEPENDENCE

Aigerim Mynbayeva Maira Kabakova Aliya Massalimova

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
СИСТЕМАТА ЗА РАЗВИТИЕ НА АКАДЕМИЧНИЯ СЪСТАВ НА РУСЕНСКИЯ УНИВЕРСИТЕТ „АНГЕЛ КЪНЧЕВ“

Христо Белоев, Ангел Смрикаров, Орлин Петров, Анелия Иванова, Галина Иванова

Книжка 2
ПРОУЧВАНЕ НА РОДИТЕЛСКОТО УЧАСТИЕ В УЧИЛИЩНИЯ ЖИВОТ В БЪЛГАРИЯ

* Този материал е изготвен въз основа на резултатите от изследването „Parental Involvement in Life of School Matters“, проведено в България в рамките на проек- та „Advancing Educational Inclusion and Quality in South East Europe“, изпълняван

ВТОРИ ФОРУМ ЗА СТРАТЕГИИ В НАУКАТА

Тошка Борисова В края на 2011 г. в София се проведе второто издание на Форум за страте- гии в науката. Основната тема бе повишаване на международната видимост и разпознаваемост на българската наука. Форумът се организира от „Elsevier“ – водеща компания за разработване и предоставяне на научни, технически и медицински информационни продукти и услуги , с подкрепата на Министер- ството на образованието, младежта и науката. След успеха на първото издание на Форума за стратегии в науката през

Книжка 1
РЕЙТИНГИ, ИНДЕКСИ, ПАРИ

Боян Захариев