Стратегии на образователната и научната политика

https://doi.org/10.53656/str2024-5s-5-com

2024/5s, стр. 53 - 63

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF UTILIZING POPULAR INTELLIGENT COMPUTER SYSTEMS IN EDUCATION

Galina Ivanova
OrcID: 0000-0001-7799-1162
E-mail: giivanova@uni-ruse.bg
University of Ruse “Angel Kanchev”
8, Studentska St
Ruse, Bulgaria
Aleksandar Ivanov
OrcID: 0000-0002-1030-0352
E-mail: -
University of Ruse “Angel Kanchev”
8, Studentska St
Ruse, Bulgaria

Резюме: Intelligent computer systems have indeed experienced rapid development in recent years. The penetration of artificial intelligence in almost all spheres will certainly change some professions. In the educational sphere for the use of the artificial intelligence are also required new digital competencies and skills that must be mastered by teachers in order to be successfully used for learning and teaching. А comparative analysis with various indicators of popular intelligent computing systems are made in the report and the possibilities for their use in the educational process are discussed. The results from study of readiness and attitude to use artificial intelligence systems of professors, teachers, students and doctoral students are presented. The results of the survey, which confirm the need to raise awareness of the possibilities of AI and to conduct more practical training to acquire digital competences and skills to use AI in education, are discussed in the paper.

Ключови думи: intelligent computer systems; artificial intelligence; digital competences; education

1. Introduction

Intelligent computer systems will certainly change the work environment and lead to the disappearance of some traditional professions. New jobs will emerge and will require new digital competences and skills. For example, in the field of autonomous and robotic systems development (Kunze et al. 2018; Chen, et al. 2022), we will need engineers and technicians to design, install, maintain and operate these systems. In the fields of e-commerce, we will need software engineers to use artificial intelligence to personalize customer offers and predict their behaviour (Khrais 2020; Kalia 2021). In medicine, artificial intelligence will be used to diagnose diseases, to plan treatment and to manage hospitals (Lee et al. 2021). As a result of digitalization and the implementation of artificial intelligence, students will be trained for new professions (Ivanova 2023; Shaukat 2020; Hristov 2023), such as: machine learning engineer, data scientist, robotics specialist.

In the educational sphere, the use of artificial intelligence will also require new skills that must be mastered by teachers and students in order to successfully use AI for learning and teaching (Liua et al.; Ahmad 2021). Teachers and students need to be taught new kinds of skills, such as how to effectively use semantics in artificial intelligence [Baeva et al., 2019] using better communication with AI and learn how to implement prompt engineering (Eager 2023; Spasić 2023).

2. Comparative analysis of popular systems with AI

А comparative analysis with various indicators of popular AI chat bots are made in Table 1.

Table 1. А comparative analysis of popular AI chat bots

IndicatorChat GPT 3.5Google Bard / GeminiBing Chat / CopilotCompanyOpen AIGoogleMicrosoftO󰀩ciallylaunched dateNovember 2022March2023/Gemini2023February 2023 / Copilot2023DatabaseTrainedwithxeddatasetTrainedwithaspecicset of data, but providealso data for current in-formationusinggooglesearchengines.Geminiis trained on a larger da-tabase.Uses an enhanced ver-sionofChatGPTandsearchestheinternetfor current data. Copilotis powered by the latestGPT 4.0 models.PriceFreeversionislim-ited to 30 messageshourlyand50mes-sageseverythreehours.For$20permontho󰀨ersfasterresponseandac-cess to new featuresin Chat GPT-4.Free versionBasicuseisstillfree.Limitations: 30 chats persessionand300chatsdaily.Anonymousses-sionhasalimitofvechats.ConversationstyleNooptionsinthechat,butinconver-sationstylecanbedenedNooptionsinthechat,but in conversation stylecan be denedThree conversation stylesoptionsinthechat:cre-ative,preciseandbal-anced style, which com-bines the best of bothImagesAtextmodelthatcannot visualize andrecognize imagesCanrecognizeimagesandvisualizeimagesfromgooglesearchbutcannotcreateimageswith AICanrecognizeimagesandgenerateimageswithAI but cannot viewreal photos from the in-ternet in chat
Data sourceslinks in thereplyNolinkstosourcesin replyWith links to sources inreplyWith links to sources inreplyWord andcharacterlimitations inquestion andanswerThe free version hasa limit of 4096 char-actersintheques-tion and 2048 in theanswer.Nocharacterlimitforprompts.Question length limit - upto 4000 charactersTasks solvingErrorswithcalcula-tionswithfractionsusingdotsorcom-masSolvestaskswithfrac-tionswithoutneedtospecify that it is fractionSolvestaskswithfrac-tionswithoutneedtospecify that it is fractionClassifyinginformation intablesGoodvisualclas-sicationinatablebut doesn’t generatemany criteriaGoodvisualclassica-tion in a table with manycriteriaGoodvisualclassica-tion in tabular form withinformation on the originofthetextandoptiontoedit the table in ExcelAudioAudio playback func-tionalityavailableinchatAudio playback function-ality available in chatAudio playback function-ality available in chatVideoNo video functional-ity available in chatNovideofunctionalityavailable in chatNovideofunctionalityavailable in chat

3. Applications of AI in education

Applications of using AI in the educational process are discussed for students, teachers and schools. For students: Personalized learning - individual study with own pace and with appropriate study materials, considering own strengths and weaknesses to improve specific achievements; Adaptive learning – optimizing education resources and supporting fast education process; Fast and automate assessment feedback – faster and accurate student assessment with possibility to compare and analyse students’ achievements; Virtual classes with AI – AI can be used for online education facilitating the perception of complex concepts, planning the educational process in time and etc.

For teachers: Creating learning materials – generating a lesson plan, generating learning content on specific topics from the curricula, etc.; Personalization of learning materials – for learners with specific educational needs (SEN), for advanced learners, personalized testing, etc.; Detection of grammatical and stylistic errors in the study material – correction of texts, students essay review with AI; Assisting with administrative work – generating a scenario for a holidays in schools, generating templates for emails to parents on various occasions (parent meeting and etc.); Structuring and summarizing a large volume of educational material – extracting keywords, classifying information in tables, etc.; Clarification of new terms with concrete definitions and examples, clarification of case studies; Test questions and tests generator based on a large volume of study material – group and individual tasks on specific topics, etc; Help with critical analysis of educational texts – assessment criteria advices.

For schools and universities: Smart classrooms – adaptable environment and access for students with SEN helping them to find things and places in the classroom with many sensors, with many possibilities for interactions with students and teachers; Smart buildings – saving energy resources, more efficient use of building space, improving students and staff safety.

4. Survey Results

A survey has been created to provide the current research with results data for readiness and attitude to use artificial intelligence systems of more than 500 participants: professors, teachers, students and doctoral students. Survey respondents are as follows: 242 school teachers (47,5 %), 136 university professors (26,7%), 52 students and pupils (10,2%), 27 doctoral students (5,3%) and 57 others. 49% of survey respondents answer that they did not use artificial intelligence, only 18% answer that they used to use AI every day and consulting with it (Fig.1). Fig. 2 shows that 67% of those respondents who use AI prefer using ChatGPT.

Figure 1. How often do you use artificial intelligence systems for training or teaching?

Figure 2. Which AI system do you prefer and use?

Fig. 3 and Fig. 4 presents comparative analysis with students and teachers’ responses. Only 30 % of students on Fig.3 response that they do not use AI, while the percentage of teachers who do not use AI is bigger – 55%. On Fig. 4 38% of those students’ respondents who use AI prefer Google Bard/Gemini, while 37% of teachers who use AI prefer ChatGPT.

On Fig. 5 246 respondents have positive attitude towards using artificial intelligence systems to improve learning and teaching and only 117 respondents have a negative attitude.

Figure 3. How often do you use artificial intelligence systems for training or teaching? – students and teachers’ responses

Figure 4. Which AI system do you prefer and use? – students and teachers’ responses

The results on Fig.6 shows that 37% of the respondents do not have a firm opinion, most likely due to a low level of awareness about the capabilities of AI.

Figure 5. What is your attitude towards using artificial intelligence systems to improve learning and teaching?

Figure 6. What is your assessment of the capabilities artificial intelligence systems provide to improve learning and teaching?

The data from Fig. 7 indicate that 424 out of 523 (87%) respondents feel they need training. This clearly shows the acute need for training professionals on how to properly use AI in their practical work. The results from Fig. 7 also confirm the conclusion drawn from the data in Fig. 6, that respondents need more awareness about the capabilities of AI.

Figure 7. What is your readiness to use artificial intelligence systems to improve learning and teaching?

Figure 8. Which capabilities of artificial intelligence systems would you use for learning or teaching?

Fig. 8 presents results about which capabilities of AI respondents would use.

258 respondents on Fig. 8 will use AI possibilities of creating educational content. 249 will use possibilities of obtaining consultations and additional study materials. 234 prefer to use AI for personalized training and instruction.

5. Conclusions

The conclusions that can be summarized from the analysis of the results of the conducted survey among over 500 professors, teachers and students are:

– Only 18 % of survey respondents use AI almost every day, but 49 percent say they have not used AI. The comparative analysis shows that students more often use AI than teachers. The results of the survey confirm the need to raise awareness of the possibilities of AI and to conduct more practical training to students and teachers to acquire digital competences and skills to use AI in education process;

– The most preferred AI system to use among respondents was ChatGPT, followed by Bing/Copilot. The least popular among respondents is Bard/Gemini. The comparative analysis shows that students prefer Google Bard/ Gemini, while teachers prefer ChatGPT.

– 48% of respondents have a positive attitude towards the use of AI in education, only 23% have a negative attitude. Artificial Intelligence is still developing in an educational context, and like every new technology that develops, it is important to be used in the classroom under the supervision of educators. Artificial intelligence should be used as advisor and should not be given a controlling role in our life.

– Based on all the responses on Fig.6, it can be concluded that there is no clearly formed opinion among those interviewed, most likely because these technologies

are too new and unfamiliar to the majority of the respondents.

– All respondents in survey indicated that they needed additional training. The most requested trainings indicated by the respondents are related to AI capabilities for creating educational content, processing and evaluating educational materials, opportunities for creating presentations.

Artificial intelligence can have many applications in education. It can help personalize the educational process by adapting learning material according to the specific needs and preferences of learners. This can significantly improve learners results and increase their motivation to study.

Acknowledgments & Funding

This study is financed by the European Union – NextGenerationEU, through the National Recovery and Resilience Plan of the Republic of Bulgaria, project № BG-RRP-2.013-0001-C01.

REFERENCES

AHMAD, S. F.; RAHMAT, M. K.; MUBARIK, M. S.; ALAM, M. M. & HYDER, S. I., 2021. Artificial intelligence and its role in education. Sustainability, vol. 13, no. 22, p. 12902. https://doi.org/10.3390/ su132212902.

BAEVA, D.; BAEV, B., 2019. Semantic approach in encoding of the meanings in Bulgarian Folklore embroidery in digital libraries. In: 2019 42nd International Convention on Information and Communication Technology, Electronics and Microelectronics (MIPRO). IEEE, pp. 1082 – 1086.

CHEN, J., SUN, J., & WANG, G., 2022. From unmanned systems to autonomous intelligent systems. Engineering, vol.12, pp. 16 – 19. DOI:10.1016/j.eng.2021.10.007.

EAGER, B., & BRUNTON, R., 2023. Prompting higher education towards AI-augmented teaching and learning practice. Journal of University Teaching & Learning Practice, vol. 20, no. 5. DOI: https://doi. org/10.53761/1.20.5.02.

HRISTOV, G.; BELOEV, I. & ZAHARIEV, P., 2023. Challenges, Requirements, Opportunities and Solutions for The Digital Transformation of the Transport Education. Strategies for Policy in Science & Education/ Strategii na Obrazovatelnata i Nauchnata Politika, vol. 31, no. 4s, pp.155 – 167. https://doi.org/10.53656/str2023-4s-13-cha.

IVANOVA, A.; IBRYAMOVA, E., 2023, The Role of Social Networks and Micro-Learning in the Digitalization of Education, Strategies for policy in science and education-Strategii na obrazovatelnata i nauchnata politika, vol. 31, no. 4s, pp. 120 – 134. DOI:10.53656/ str2023-4s-10-the.

KALIA, P., 2021. Artificial intelligence in e-commerce: a business process analysis. In: Artificial Intelligence, pp. 9 – 19. CRC Press.

KHRAIS, L. T., 2020. Role of artificial intelligence in shaping consumer demand in E-commerce. Future Internet, vol. 12, no. 12, https://doi. org/10.3390/fi12120226.

KUNZE, L., HAWES, N., DUCKETT, T., HANHEIDE, M., & KRAJNÍK, T., 2018. Artificial intelligence for long-term robot autonomy: A survey. IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters, vol. 3, no. 4, pp. 4023 – 4030.

LEE, D., & YOON, S. N., 2021. Application of artificial intelligence-based technologies in the healthcare industry: Opportunities and challenges. International journal of environmental research and public health, vol. 18, no. 1, p. 271. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18010271.

LIUA, Y., SALEHB, S., & HUANG, J., 2021. Artificial intelligence in promoting teaching and learning transformation in schools. Artificial Intelligence, vol. 15, no. 3. DOI:10.53333/IJICC2013/15369.

SHAUKAT, K.; IQBAL, F.; ALAM, T. M.; AUJLA, G. K.; DEVNATH, L.; KHAN, A. G. & RUBAB, A., 2020. The impact of artificial intelligence and robotics on the future employment opportunities. Trends in Computer Science and Information Technology, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 050 – 054.

SPASIĆ, A. J. & JANKOVIĆ, D. S., 2023. Using ChatGPT standard prompt engineering techniques in lesson preparation: role, instructions and seed-word prompts. In: 2023 58th International Scientific Conference on Information, Communication and Energy Systems and Technologies (ICEST), IEEE, pp. 47 – 50.

2025 година
Книжка 6
UNLOCKING THE POTENTIAL OF ESG AND AI IN HIGHER EDUCATION FINANCE: INSIGHTS FROM A STUDY ACROSS FIVE EUROPEAN COUNTRIES

Tina Vukasović, Rok Strašek, Liliya Terzieva;, Elenita Velikova, Justyna Tomala, Maria Urbaniec, Jarosław Pawlik, Michael Murg, Anita Maček

THE ROLE OF HIGHER EDUCATION FOR THE PROFESSIONAL REALIZATION OF STUDENTS – PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS

Anny Atanasova, Viktoriya Kalaydzhieva, Radostina Yuleva-Chuchulayna, Kalina Durova-Angelova

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
ТРАНСФОРМАЦИИ НА ПАЗАРА НА ТРУДА И НУЖДАТА ОТ ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛНИ РЕФОРМИ

Ваня Иванова, Андрей Василев, Калоян Ганев, Ралица Симеонова-Ганева

Книжка 3
FORMING ENTREPRENEURIAL CULTURE THROUGH EDUCATION

Milena Filipova, Adriana Atanasova

Книжка 2s
THE STATE OF INCLUSION IN ADAPTED BASKETBALL

Stefka Djobova, Ivelina Kirilova

Книжка 2
MODEL OF PROFESSIONALLY DIRECTED TRAINING OF FUTURE ENGINEER-TEACHERS

Ivan Beloev, Valentina Vasileva, Іnna Savytska, Oksana Bulgakova, Lesia Zbaravska, Olha Chaikovska

DETERMINANTS AFFECTING ACADEMIC STAFF SATISFACTION WITH ONLINE LEARNING IN HIGHER MEDICAL EDUCATION

Miglena Tarnovska, ;, Rumyana Stoyanova, ;, Angelina Kirkova-Bogdanova;, Rositsa Dimova

Книжка 1s
AN INNOVATIVE MODEL FOR DEVELOPING DIGITAL COMPETENCES OF SOCIAL WORKERS

Lyudmila Vekova, Tanya Vazova, Penyo Georgiev, Ekaterina Uzhikanova-Kovacheva

Книжка 1
2024 година
Книжка 6s
DISRUPTIVE TECHNOLOGIES RISK MANAGEMENT

Miglena Molhova-Vladova, Ivaylo B. Ivanov

Книжка 6
AN INTEGRATIVE APPROACH TO ORGANIZING THE FORMATION OF STUDENTS’ COGNITIVE INDEPENDENCE IN CONDITIONS OF INTENSIFICATION OF LEARNING ACTIVITIES

Albina Volkotrubova, Aidai Kasymova, Zoriana Hbur, Antonina Kichuk, Svitlana Koshova, Svitlana Khodakivska

ИНОВАТИВЕН МОДЕЛ НА ПРОЕКТНО БАЗИРАНО ОБУЧЕНИЕ НА ГИМНАЗИАЛНИ УЧИТЕЛИ: ДОБРА ПРАКТИКА ОТ УниБИТ

Жоржета Назърска, Александър Каракачанов, Магдалена Гарванова, Нина Дебрюне

Книжка 5s
КОНЦЕПТУАЛНА РАМКА ЗА ИЗПОЛЗВАНЕ НА ИЗКУСТВЕНИЯ ИНТЕЛЕКТ ВЪВ ВИСШЕТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Акад. Христо Белоев, Валентина Войноховска, Ангел Смрикаров

ИЗСЛЕДВАНЕ ПРИЛОЖИМОСТТА НА БЛОКОВИ ВЕРИГИ ОТ ПЪРВО НИВО (L1) В СИСТЕМА ЗА ЕЛЕКТРОННО ОБУЧЕНИЕ

Андриан Минчев, Ваня Стойкова, Галя Шивачева, Доц Анелия Иванова

ПРЕДИЗВИКАТЕЛСТВА ПРИ ПРОМЯНА НА ПЛАТФОРМИ ЗА ДИСТАНЦИОННО ОБУЧЕНИЕ

Антон Недялков, Милена Кирова, Мирослава Бонева

APPLICATION OF ZSPACE TECHNOLOGY IN THE DISCIPLINES OF THE STEM CYCLE

Boyana Ivanova, Kamelia Shoilekova, Desislava Atanasova, Rumen Rusev

TEACHERS' ADAPTATION TO CHANGES IN AN INCREASINGLY COMPLEX WORLD THROUGH THE USE OF AI

Zhanat Nurbekova, Kanagat Baigusheva, Kalima Tuenbaeva, Bakyt Nurbekov, Tsvetomir Vassilev

АТОСЕКУНДНОТО ОБУЧЕНИЕ – МЕТАФОРА НА ДНЕШНОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Юлия Дончева, Денис Асенов, Ангел Смрикаров, Цветомир Василев

Книжка 5
Книжка 4s
Книжка 4
MANAGERIAL ASPECTS OF COOPERATION AMONG HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS AND THEIR STAKEHOLDERS

Olha Prokopenko, Svitlana Perova, Tokhir Rakhimov, Mykola Kunytskyi, Iryna Leshchenko

Книжка 3s
Книжка 3
Книжка 2
FORMATION OF PROFESSIONAL SKILLS OF AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERS DURING LABORATORY PRACTICE WHEN STUDYING FUNDAMENTAL SCIENCE

Ivan Beloev, Oksana Bulgakova, Oksana Zakhutska, Maria Bondar, Lesia Zbaravska

ИМИДЖ НА УНИВЕРСИТЕТА

Галя Христозова

Книжка 1s
COMPETITIVENESS AS A RESULT OF CREATIVITY AND INNOVATION

Nikolay Krushkov, Ralitza Zayakova-Krushkova

INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND SECURITY IN THE INTEGRATED CIRCUITS INDUSTRY

Ivan Nachev, Yuliana Tomova, Iskren Konstantinov, Marina Spasova

Книжка 1
PROBLEMS AND PERSPECTIVES FOR SOCIAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN HIGHER EDUCATION

Milena Filipova, Olha Prokopenko, Igor Matyushenko, Olena Khanova, Olga Shirobokova, Ardian Durmishi

2023 година
Книжка 6s
DEVELOPMENT OF A COMMON INFORMATION SYSTEM TO CREATE A DIGITAL CAREER CENTER TOGETHER WITH PARTNER HIGHER SCHOOLS

Yordanka Angelova, Rossen Radonov, Vasil Kuzmov, Stela Zhorzh Derelieva-Konstantinova

DRAFTING A DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION STRATEGY FOR PROJECT MANAGEMENT SECTOR – EMPIRICAL STUDY ON UAE

Mounir el Khatib, Shikha al Ali, Ibrahim Alharam, Ali Alhajeri, Gabriela Peneva, Jordanka Angelova, Mahmoud Shanaa

VOYAGE OF LEARNING: CRUISE SHIPS WEATHER ROUTING AND MARITIME EDUCATION

Svetlana Dimitrakieva, Dobrin Milev, Christiana Atanasova

СТРУКТУРНИ ПРОМЕНИ В ОБУЧЕНИЕТО НА МЕНИДЖЪРИ ЗА ИНДУСТРИЯ 5.0

Недко Минчев, Венета Христова, Иван Стоянов

RESEARCH OF THE INNOVATION CAPACITY OF AGRICULTURAL PRODUCERS

Siya Veleva, ; Margarita Mondeshka, Anka Tsvetanova

Книжка 6
Книжка 5s
ВИДОВЕ ТРАВМИ В ПАРАШУТИЗМА И ПРЕВЕНЦИЯТА ИМ

Капитан III ранг Георги Калинов

Книжка 5
Книжка 4s
DETERMINING THE DEGREE OF DIGITALIZATION OF A HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTION

Acad. Hristo Beloev, Angel Smrikarov, Valentina Voinohovska, Galina Ivanova

ОТ STEM КЪМ BEST: ДВА СТАНДАРТА, ЕДНА ЦЕЛ

Андрей Захариев, Стефан Симеонов, Таня Тодорова

Книжка 4
EFFECT OF RESILIENCE ON BURNOUT IN ONLINE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT

Radina Stoyanova, Sonya Karabeliova, Petya Pandurova, Nadezhda Zheckova, Kaloyan Mitev

Книжка 3s
INTELLIGENT ANIMAL HUSBANDRY: FARMER ATTITUDES AND A ROADMAP FOR IMPLEMENTATION

Dimitrios Petropoulos, Koutroubis Fotios, Petya Biolcheva, Evgeni Valchev

Книжка 3
STUDY OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE USE OF COMMUNICATIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE EDUCATIONAL PROCESS OF ENGINEERS TRAINING

Ivan Beloev, Valentina Vasileva, Sergii Bilan, Maria Bondar, Oksana Bulgakova, Lyubov Shymko

Книжка 2
РАЗПОЛОЖЕНИЕ НА ВИСШИТЕ УЧИЛИЩА В БЪЛГАРИЯ В КОНТЕКСТА НА ФОРМИРАНЕ НА ПАЗАРА НА ТРУДА

Цветелина Берберова-Вълчева, Камен Петров, Николай Цонков

Книжка 1
MODERNIZATION OF THE CONTENT OF THE LECTURE COURSE IN PHYSICS FOR TRAINING FUTURE AGRICULTURAL ENGINEERS

Ivan Beloev, Valentina Vasileva, Vasyl Shynkaruk, Oksana Bulgakova, Maria Bondar, Lesia Zbaravska, Sergii Slobodian

2022 година
Книжка 6
ORGANIZATION OF AN INCLUSIVE EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT FOR THE STUDENTS WITH SPECIAL NEEDS

Halyna Bilavych, Nataliia Bakhmat, Tetyana Pantiuk, Mykola Pantiuk, Borys Savchuk

ДИГИТАЛИЗАЦИЯ НА ОБРАЗОВАНИЕТО В БЪЛГАРИЯ: СЪСТОЯНИЕ И ОБЩИ ТЕНДЕНЦИИ

Теодора Върбанова, Албена Вуцова, Николай Нетов

Книжка 5
ПРАВОТО НА ИЗБОР В ЖИВОТА НА ДЕЦАТА В РЕПУБЛИКА БЪЛГАРИЯ

Сийка Чавдарова-Костова, Даниела Рачева, Екатерина Томова, Росица Симеонова

Книжка 4
DIAGNOSIS AS A TOOL FOR MONITORING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF ADDICTION PREVENTION IN ADOLESCENTS

O.A. Selivanova, N.V. Bystrova, I.I. Derecha, T.S. Mamontova, O.V. Panfilova

Книжка 3
ПУБЛИЧНОТО РАЗБИРАНЕ НА НАУКАТА В МРЕЖОВИЯ СВЯТ

Светломир Здравков, Мартин Й. Иванов, Петя Климентова

Книжка 2
Книжка 1
ДИГИТАЛНАТА ИНТЕРАКЦИЯ ПРЕПОДАВАТЕЛ – СТУДЕНТ В ОНЛАЙН ОБУЧЕНИЕТО В МЕДИЦИНСКИТЕ УНИВЕРСИТЕТИ

Миглена Търновска, Румяна Стоянова, Боряна Парашкевова, Юлияна Маринова

2021 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4s
SIGNAL FOR HELP

Ina Vladova, Milena Kuleva

Книжка 4
PREMISES FOR A MULTICULTURAL APPROACH TO EDUCATION

Anzhelina Koriakina, Lyudmila Amanbaeva

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
ПЪРВА СЕДМИЦА ДИСТАНЦИОННО ОБУЧЕНИЕ В СУ „ИВАН ВАЗОВ“ В СТАРА ЗАГОРА

Тони Чехларова, Динко Цвятков, Неда Чехларова

Книжка 1
METHODOLOGY OF SAFETY AND QUALITY OF LIFE ON THE BASIS OF NOOSPHERIC EDUCATION SYSTEM FORMATION

Nataliia Bakhmat, Nataliia Ridei, Nataliia Tytova, Vladyslava Liubarets, Oksana Katsero

2020 година
Книжка 6
HIGHER EDUCATION AS A PUBLIC GOOD

Yulia Nedelcheva, Miroslav Nedelchev

Книжка 5
НАСЪРЧАВАНЕ НА СЪТРУДНИЧЕСТВОТО МЕЖДУ ВИСШИТЕ УЧИЛИЩА И БИЗНЕСА

Добринка Стоянова, Блага Маджурова, Гергана Димитрова, Стефан Райчев

Книжка 4
THE STRATEGY OF HUMAN RIGHTS STUDY IN EDUCATION

Anush Balian, Nataliya Seysebayeva, Natalia Efremova, Liliia Danylchenko

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
МИГРАЦИЯ И МИГРАЦИОННИ ПРОЦЕСИ

Веселина Р. Иванова

SOCIAL STATUS OF DISABLED PEOPLE IN RUSSIA

Elena G. Pankova, Tatiana V. Soloveva, Dinara A. Bistyaykina, Olga M. Lizina

Книжка 1
ETHNIC UPBRINGING AS A PART OF THE ETHNIC CULTURE

Sholpankulova Gulnar Kenesbekovna

2019 година
Книжка 6
EMOTIONAL COMPETENCE OF THE SOCIAL TEACHER

Kadisha K. Shalgynbayeva, Ulbosin Zh.Tuyakova

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
УЧИЛИЩЕТО НА БЪДЕЩЕТО

Наталия Витанова

Книжка 2
Книжка 1
POST-GRADUATE QUALIFICATION OF TEACHERS IN INTERCULTURAL EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT

Irina Koleva, Veselin Tepavicharov, Violeta Kotseva, Kremena Yordanova

ДЕЦАТА В КОНСТИТУЦИОННИТЕ НОРМИ НА БЪЛГАРИЯ

Румен Василев, Весела Марева

СЪСТОЯНИЕ НА БЪЛГАРСКОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Анелия Любенова, Любомир Любенов

ЕДИН НОВ УЧЕБНИК

Ирина Колева

2018 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
A NEW AWARD FOR PROFESSOR MAIRA KABAKOVA

Irina Koleva, Editor-in-

Книжка 4
Книжка 3
BLENDED EDUCATION IN HIGHER SCHOOLS: NEW NETWORKS AND MEDIATORS

Nikolay Tsankov, Veska Gyuviyska, Milena Levunlieva

ВЗАИМОВРЪЗКАТА МЕЖДУ СПОРТА И ПРАВОТО

Ивайло Прокопов, Елица Стоянова

ХИМЕРНИТЕ ГРУПИ В УЧИЛИЩЕ

Яна Рашева-Мерджанова

Книжка 2
Книжка 1
2017 година
Книжка 6
ЗНАЧИМОСТТА НА УЧЕНЕТО: АНАЛИЗ НА ВРЪЗКИТЕ МЕЖДУ ГЛЕДНИТЕ ТОЧКИ НА УЧЕНИЦИ, РОДИТЕЛИ И УЧИТЕЛИ

Илиана Мирчева, Елена Джамбазова, Снежана Радева, Деян Велковски

Книжка 5
ОРГАНИЗАЦИОННА КУЛТУРА В УЧИЛИЩЕ

Ивайло Старибратов, Лилия Бабакова

Книжка 4
КОУЧИНГ. ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЕН КОУЧИНГ

Наталия Витанова, Нели Митева

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
Книжка 1
ЕМПАТИЯ И РЕФЛЕКСИЯ

Нели Кънева, Кристиана Булдеева

2016 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
Книжка 2
Книжка 1
2015 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4
ПРАГМАТИЧНАТА ДИДАКТИКА

Николай Колишев

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
Книжка 1
2014 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
КОХЕРЕНТНОСТ НА ПОЛИТИКИ

Албена Вуцова, Лиляна Павлова

Книжка 4
USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

Книжка 3
USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

Книжка 2
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT OF UNIVERSITY FACULTY: А SOCIOLOGICAL ANALYSIS

Gulnar Toltaevna Balakayeva, Alken Shugaybekovich Tokmagambetov, Sapar Imangalievich Ospanov

USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

Книжка 1
РЕФЛЕКСИЯТА В ИНТЕГРАТИВНОТО ПОЛЕ НА МЕТОДИКАТА НА ОБУЧЕНИЕТО ПО БИОЛОГИЯ

Иса Хаджиали, Наташа Цанова, Надежда Райчева, Снежана Томова

USING THE RESULTS OF A NATIONAL ASSESSMENT OF EDUCATIONAL ACHIEVEMENT

Thomas Kellaghan, Vincent Greaney, T. Scott Murray

2013 година
Книжка 6
Книжка 5
Книжка 4
QUESTIONNAIRE DEVELOPMENT

ÎÖÅÍßÂÀÍÅÒÎ

Книжка 3
MASS MEDIA CULTURE IN KAZAKHSTAN

Aktolkyn Kulsariyeva Yerkin Massanov Indira Alibayeva

РЪКОВОДСТВО ЗА СЪСТАВЯНЕ НА ТЕСТОВЕ*

Фернандо Картрайт, Джери Мусио

РОССИЙСКАЯ СИСТЕМА ОЦЕНКИ КАЧЕСТВА ОБРАЗОВАНИЯ: ГЛАВНЫЕ УРОКИ

В. Болотов / И. Вальдман / Г. Ковалёва / М. Пинская

Книжка 2
ОЦЕНЯВАНЕ НА ГРАЖДАНСКИТЕ КОМПЕТЕНТНОСТИ НА УЧЕНИЦИТЕ: ПРЕДИЗВИКАТЕЛСТВА И ВЪЗМОЖНОСТИ

Светла Петрова Център за контрол и оценка на качеството на училищното образование

РЪКОВОДСТВО ЗА СЪСТАВЯНЕ НА ТЕСТОВЕ*

Фернандо Картрайт, Джери Мусио

Книжка 1
Уважаеми читатели,

вет, както и от международния борд за предоставените статии и студии, за да могат да бъдат идентифицирани в полето на образованието пред широката аудитория от педа- гогически специалисти във всички степени на образователната ни система. Благодаря за техния всеотдаен и безвъзмезден труд да създават и популяризират мрежа от научни съобщества по профила на списанието и да насърчават научните изследвания. Благодаря на рецензентите от национално представените висши училища, на- учни институции и

РЪКОВОДСТВО ЗА СЪСТАВЯНЕ НА ТЕСТОВЕ

Фернандо Картрайт, Джери Мусио

2012 година
Книжка 6
DEVELOPMENT OF SCIENCE IN KAZAKHSTAN IN THE PERIOD OF INDEPENDENCE

Aigerim Mynbayeva Maira Kabakova Aliya Massalimova

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
СИСТЕМАТА ЗА РАЗВИТИЕ НА АКАДЕМИЧНИЯ СЪСТАВ НА РУСЕНСКИЯ УНИВЕРСИТЕТ „АНГЕЛ КЪНЧЕВ“

Христо Белоев, Ангел Смрикаров, Орлин Петров, Анелия Иванова, Галина Иванова

Книжка 2
ПРОУЧВАНЕ НА РОДИТЕЛСКОТО УЧАСТИЕ В УЧИЛИЩНИЯ ЖИВОТ В БЪЛГАРИЯ

* Този материал е изготвен въз основа на резултатите от изследването „Parental Involvement in Life of School Matters“, проведено в България в рамките на проек- та „Advancing Educational Inclusion and Quality in South East Europe“, изпълняван

ВТОРИ ФОРУМ ЗА СТРАТЕГИИ В НАУКАТА

Тошка Борисова В края на 2011 г. в София се проведе второто издание на Форум за страте- гии в науката. Основната тема бе повишаване на международната видимост и разпознаваемост на българската наука. Форумът се организира от „Elsevier“ – водеща компания за разработване и предоставяне на научни, технически и медицински информационни продукти и услуги , с подкрепата на Министер- ството на образованието, младежта и науката. След успеха на първото издание на Форума за стратегии в науката през

Книжка 1
РЕЙТИНГИ, ИНДЕКСИ, ПАРИ

Боян Захариев