Педагогика

https://doi.org/10.53656/ped2024-7.05

2024/7, стр. 955 - 969

EXAMINING WRITING FEEDBACK DYNAMICS FROM CHATGPT AI AND HUMAN EDUCATORS: A COMPARATIVE STUDY

Ekrem Solak
OrcID: 0000-0002-9817-4636
WoSID: HKM-8306-2023
E-mail: ekremsolak@cityu.edu.mo
City University of Macau
Macau China

Резюме: As technology increasingly influences educational practices, it is crucial to comprehend the impact and effectiveness of AI in comparison to human-driven methodologies. In the field of language learning and writing instruction, one notable development is the emergence of AI-generated writing feedback tools. These tools, exemplified by ChatGPT in this study, promise efficiency, objectivity, and detailed insights for learners. This study aims to investigate the comparative effectiveness of an artificial intelligence (AI) automated writing feedback tool and human teacher feedback in enhancing the writing skills of English Language Learners. The research was conducted on fifteen third-year undergraduate students in the discipline of English Language Education, using a phenomenological design. The study collected qualitative data through assignments and feedback given to students at a higher education institution. The findings suggest that while human teachers were praised for their understanding, personalized guidance, and emotional intelligence in providing feedback, AI-generated feedback was considered more detailed and comprehensive. It highlights the importance of balancing efficiency with the human touch in the feedback process. This study makes a significant contribution to the ongoing discourse surrounding the integration of AI in education and its impact on the student-teacher dynamic.

Ключови думи: AI writing feedback; Al vs human teacher; ChatGPT writing; artificial intelligence and writing

1. Introduction

The use of AI in education presents both exciting opportunities and challenges. Automated writing feedback systems can provide learners with immediate responses, aiding in the development of writing skills and fostering a more efficient learning process. However, questions persist regarding the capacity of AI models to comprehend the intricacies of language, understand context, and deliver feedback that is not only accurate but also pedagogically effective.

This study explores the comparative dynamics between AI-generated feedback and human teacher feedback. Although AI models can analyze vast datasets and learn patterns from a multitude of writing styles, human teachers possess the unique ability to empathize with the individual needs and nuances of each learner. The qualitative aspects of feedback, such as encouragement, motivation, and personalized guidance, are often considered integral components of the learning experience, and it remains to be seen whether AI can successfully replicate these aspects.

The study evaluates the strengths and limitations of both approaches, shedding light on the efficacy, reliability, and pedagogical implications of AI-generated feedback in the context of writing instruction. By employing a multidimensional assessment framework, encompassing aspects such as content, vocabulary, grammatical accuracy, coherence, clarity, and engagement, this study aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the comparative dynamics between AIdriven feedback and human teacher feedback.

This research contributes valuable insights to the ongoing discourse on the integration of AI in education by examining sample writings evaluated by both ChatGPT and human teachers. The outcomes of this research may pave the way for designing educational interventions that harness the strengths of both AI and human educators, ensuring a balanced and effective approach to writing pedagogy in the digital age.

2. Theoretical Framework

The underlying theories provide a comprehensive framework for understanding the differences between Artificial Intelligence (AI) and human teacher on writing feedback. The integration of these theoretical perspectives can enhance the design and implementation of feedback mechanisms to optimize the learning experience for individuals seeking to improve their writing skills.

Constructivist Learning Theory

According to Constructivist Learning Theory, learners construct knowledge by building on their existing mental frameworks (Suhendi and Purwarno 2018). Therefore, in the context of writing feedback, it is crucial for learners to engage with feedback that aligns with their current understanding and knowledge.

Technology Acceptance Model (TAM)

The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is a widely-used framework for understanding individuals’ acceptance and use of technology. TAM asserts that perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use are key determinants influencing users’ attitudes and intentions towards adopting and using a particular technology (Davis 1989). In the context of writing feedback, TAM can be applied to comprehend how users, such as students or writers, perceive and interact with technology-driven feedback systems.

Human-AI Interaction Theory

Human-AI interaction theory asserts that the relationship between individuals and artificial intelligence systems can lead to collaboration, communication, and synergy (Brey and Søraker 2009). In the context of writing feedback, this theory posits that the relationship between students and AI tools can significantly improve the feedback process.

3. Literature Review

The effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in writing tools has been extensively researched in education, particularly in terms of its ability to enhance the writing skills of diverse learners. Taşkıran et al. (2024) examined the impact of Automated Feedback (AF) on the writing proficiency of EFL learners in open and distance learning. They found that AF significantly contributed to the development of writing competence, motivation, learning environment, and distance learning.

Liu et al. (2023) proposed an AI-supported English writing approach based on a reflective thinking promotion mechanism, which significantly improved learners’ English writing performance, self-efficacy, and self-regulated learning. The approach reduced cognitive load, showcasing the potential of AI in enhancing EFL writing quality.

Bewersdoff et al. (2023) demonstrated the effectiveness of AI in education by developing an AI system based on GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 for error detection in inquiry-based learning. The results indicated that AI system accurately identified fundamental student errors, providing a strong foundation for personalized feedback.

Fawaz (2023) conducted a research on Wordtune’s impact on Saudi students’ writing, revealing that using Wordtune significantly improved the experimental group’s writing, outperforming the control group in the final writing exam.

Shum et al. (2023) analyzed the use of open AF tools by teachers from the perspective of teacher feedback literacy. Their study highlights the importance of teacher feedback competencies, in effectively utilizing open AI tools to enhance teaching practices.

Yang et al. (2023) explored EFL students’ interactions with Pigai, the largest AI-programmed AWE in China. Their findings demonstrated a focus on error corrective feedback and provision of rich linguistic resources, albeit without examples and contextual information.

Sun (2023) examined the potential use of generative AI in ESL Writing Assessment, with a specific focus on IELTS Writing Tasks. The researcher analyzed the strengths and weaknesses of generative AI tools and demonstrated how they can assist researchers in writing informative articles more efficiently.

Chen (2022) investigated the feedback and effect of Aim Writing on college students’ writing in China. The results suggested that Aim Writing’s performance was inadequate and a hybrid model incorporating both AES and instructor’s feedback is necessary.

Wang (2022) examined students’ expectations and perceived effectiveness of computer-assisted review tools, revealing high expectations for such tools. Computer scoring feedback was found more effective than teacher scoring feedback, significantly improving students’ independent learning ability and English writing skills.

Tonsic (2021) investigated the effect of an AI grammar checker on the pedagogy of high school English teachers. The study found that the use of online grammar checkers prompt critical reflection on assessing Standard English in high schools.

Nazari et al. (2021) demonstrated the effectiveness of Grammarly, an AIpowered writing tool, for English postgraduate students. Their study revealed that Grammarly had a positive impact on cognitive, non-cognitive, and emotional domains. These findings suggest that Grammarly can be a valuable assistive tool for non-native postgraduate students in English academic writing.

Lim and Phua (2019) focused on the effectiveness of a Linguistic Feedback Tool (LiFT) in improving students’ English composition. By identifying and providing feedback on language accuracy, LİFT has the potential to reduce teacher marking time.

In summary, the reviewed literature illustrates the diverse applications of AI in writing tools, emphasizing their positive impact on various aspects of writing skills, ranging from cognitive and emotional domains to error detection, personalized feedback, and teacher feedback competencies.

4. Method

This study aimed to examine the effectiveness of an artificial intelligence automated writing feedback tool and human teacher’s feedback in enhancing the writing skills of English Language Learners. This study used a phenomenological design, which is a type of qualitative research. In phenomenology, a researcher explores different perceptions of a particular phenomenon. The researcher attempts to identify and describe aspects of each individual’s perceptions of their experience in some detail (Fraenkel et al. 2012). The study involved fifteen 3rd year undergraduate students from the Department of English Language Education, comprising of 11 females and 4 males with similar educational background and English language proficiency. The participants were selected on a voluntary basis and were assigned to write a 450 – 500-word essay on a given topic. These assignments were evaluated by ChatGPT, an artificial intelligence writing feedback tool, and a human teacher. The students were then given the reports of evaluation and asked to compare the pros and cons of both evaluation types in terms of content, vocabulary, grammar, cohesion, coherence and overall evaluation.

5. Findings and Results

The final evaluation reports of the students were categorized into themes such as content, vocabulary, grammar, cohesion, coherence and overall evaluation. The researcher selected the most significant responses from the respondents (coded R1 to R15) for each theme and presented them in tables. The data then was interpreted to draw implications for Constructivist Learning Theory, Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Human-AI Interaction Theory.

Table 1. Statements Related to the Feedback Under the Theme of Content

R2In terms of content, the teacher only gave a ‚good‘rating,whereas theAI gave the reasonwhyitwas good enough in terms of content, being that specific examples or detailswere provided,the focuswas obvious and the expressionwas clear enough.R4Both theAI and the teacher could understand the logic of the content, but theAI gave a moredetailed suggestion for revision.R6TheAI begins by summarizing the points of the article and providing some usable ideas tostrengthen your argument.R14TheAI‘s feedback summarized the content of my essay in more detail and gave specificsuggestions for revision.

Implications for Constructivist Learning Theory under the theme of content

In the context of Constructivist Learning Theory, the AI’s feedback aligns with the principles of active engagement and knowledge construction. The focus on specific examples encourages reflective learning and the construction of knowledge regarding effective content. This demonstrates that the AI not only recognizes existing logic but also actively engages the student in the construction of improved content. This aligns with the theory’s emphasis on learners actively shaping their understanding. The AI’s approach of summarizing key points and providing actionable ideas supports this theory by encouraging students to engage with the material. By summarizing and suggesting improvements, the AI prompts the student to reflect on the content’s structure and argumentation, fostering a deeper understanding and construction of knowledge. The feedback provided enables the student to actively engage in revising and developing a more refined understanding of the content.

Implications for Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) under the theme of content

The AI’s feedback provides specific reasons for the ‘good’ rating, contributing to the perceived usefulness of the technology. The detailed insights into the content’s strengths enhance the user’s understanding of why the content is considered effective, positively influencing the user’s attitude towards accepting and utilizing AI-generated feedback. The AI’s more detailed suggestions for revision can significantly impact the perceived usefulness of the technology. The AI’s approach to summarizing points and providing usable ideas aligns with TAM by emphasizing the perceived usefulness of the technology. The detailed summary and specific suggestions for revision contribute to the perceived usefulness of the AI.

Implications for Human-AI Interaction Theory under the theme of content

Clear communication enhances the user’s understanding and promotes a positive interaction with the AI system. The AI’s more detailed suggestions for revision demonstrate a collaborative interaction, where the AI actively engages with the user in content improvement. This aligns the focus of Human-AI Interaction Theory on a cooperative and adaptive relationship between humans and AI systems, fostering a more effective interaction. The AI’s approach of summarizing points and providing usable ideas supports a positive and usercentered interaction. The clarity and usefulness of the feedback enhance the user’s experience, fostering a dynamic and effective interaction based on mutual understanding and collaboration.

Table 2. Statements Related to the Feedback Under the Theme of Vocabulary

R2The teacher marked some of thevocabulary and sentences and revised them. theAI alsogavevery detailed information about the areas of improvement invocabulary. Here both sidesdid well.R4Both theAI and the teacher gave some nicewords to startwith and then gave some detailedsuggestions onword choice.The teacher‘s suggestionswere even more specific.R6AI thought that therewas still room for improvement in myword choice, but it presented fewerexamples than a real personwould, although this problem can be improved by changing theAI‘s instructions.R14TheAI gave suggestions for replacementwords,while the teacher marked the misspelledwords in the text, both ofwhichwere clear.

Implications for Constructivist Learning Theory under the theme of vocabulary

This approach encourages active participation by highlighting specific areas for improvement, encouraging a reflective process in which the learner actively considers and internalizes vocabulary improvements. The collaborative effort between the AI and teacher, providing positive words and detailed suggestions on word choice, is line with Constructivist Learning Theory. Learners are actively involved in understanding and refining their language use, building their vocabulary through specific suggestions and examples. Both the AI’s suggestion of alternative words and the teacher’s marking of misspelled words contribute to a constructivist approach. By focusing on specific language elements, learners are encouraged to actively engage with vocabulary improvement, in line with the theory’s emphasis on individualized learning.

Implications for Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) under the theme of vocabulary

The detailed information provided by both the teacher and AI contributes to the perceived usefulness of the feedback systems, supporting TAM principles. Learners are likely to accept and engage with feedback that provides specific information to improve their vocabulary, thereby enhancing their understanding and application. The specific word suggestions from both the AI and the teacher contribute to the perceived usefulness and acceptance of these systems. The collaborative effort to improve vocabulary is consistent with TAM’s emphasis on user attitudes and perceived usefulness as determinants of technology acceptance. Both the AI and teacher contributing to vocabulary improvement support perceived usefulness, a key factor in technology acceptance.

Implications for Human-AI Interaction Theory under the theme of vocabulary

The teacher’s marking and revising, together with the AI’s detailed information, contribute to a positive human-AI interaction. This collaboration ensures that learners receive comprehensive and effective feedback, fostering a positive and beneficial interaction. Both the AI and the teacher providing specific words and detailed suggestions support a positive human-AI interaction. The combination of AI insights and human expertise creates a collaborative environment that enhances the user experience. The AI’s recognition of areas for improvement and ability to refine the AI instructions reflect a dynamic and adaptive human-AI interaction. This responsiveness contributes to a more effective and user-friendly interaction. Users receive clear and actionable feedback, promoting an effective collaboration between the human and AI components.

Table 3. Statements Related to the Feedback Under the Theme of Grammar

R4Both theAI and the teacher gave some suggestions for revision, but theAI‘swere moredetailed.R5The underlining of grammar errors in the essaywasvery detailed, helping me understandmywriting issues clearly.This led me to focus only on grammatical errors and ignoreotherareaswhere the essay could be improved.R7The obvious grammar mistakeswere highlighted in teacher feedback, but some of themwerenot refined.When I noticed them, I thought aboutwhat mistakes I had made here, and howI could clarify them to make it more clearly.R9Some kinds of errors such as grammar, spelling may be easily and accurately identified byanAI than by a human teacher.

Implications for Constructivist Learning Theory under the theme of grammar

The AI’s more detailed suggestions for revision are in line with Constructivist Learning Theory as they encourage active engagement and reflection. The detailed feedback provided to learners offers specific insights, fostering a deeper understanding of writing principles and prompting them to actively consider and apply improvements. By concentrating on specific aspects, learners actively engage with and internalize corrections, potentially leading to a more targeted improvement in their writing skills. The teacher’s identification of grammar mistakes and subsequent reflection could be seen as being in line with Constructivist Learning Theory. This approach encourages learners to actively identify and address errors, promoting a self-directed learning process. The AI’s accurate identification of grammar and spelling provides learners with precise feedback.

Implications for Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) under the theme of grammar

Clear and comprehensive feedback can enhance collaboration between the user and the AI, ultimately improving the overall user experience. The AI’s more detailed suggestions can contribute to perceived usefulness, which is a key factor in TAM. It is likely that users will accept and engage with technology that provides specific and detailed feedback, enhancing their understanding and facilitating improvement. The detailed underlining of grammar errors by the AI may contribute to perceived usefulness, supporting TAM principles. The teacher’s highlighting of obvious grammar mistakes and subsequent reflection may contribute to the perceived usefulness of their teacher’s feedback. Users are more likely to accept and engage with feedback that prompts them to reflect on and improve specific areas of their writing. The AI’s ability to identify errors aligns with TAM, as it enhances perceived usefulness. Users are likely to accept technology that efficiently identifies and addresses writing errors, contributing to a positive attitude towards the system.

Implications for Human-AI Interaction Theory under the theme of grammar

Providing clear and comprehensive feedback can foster effective collaboration between the user and the AI, ultimately improving the overall user experience. The AI suggestions have the potential to enhance the human-AI interaction. The combination of teacher feedback and user reflection creates a collaborative learning environment.

Table 4. Statements Related to the Feedback Under the Theme of Cohesion
and Coherence

R2In terms of coherence and cohesion, the teacher gave a rating ofvery good. theAI, on the otherhand, pointed out that my essaywas coherent, yet I should have used more transitional phrasesor sentences to enhance cohesion.R4Since theAI didn‘t know the requirements of my paragraph, it just suggested that I follow thegeneral rules ofwriting;while the teacher knew that Iwas asked towrite simple paragraphs, hethoughtmy work wasOK.

Implications for Constructivist Learning Theory under the theme of Cohesion and Coherence

The AI’s suggestion to use more transitional phrases aligns with Constructivist Learning Theory by encouraging active engagement in improving writing skills. The feedback prompts the learner to reflect on the coherence and cohesion of their essay, fostering a deeper understanding of how transitional elements contribute to effective writing. The AI’s suggestion to follow general writing rules, despite not knowing specific paragraph requirements, may be consistent with Constructivist Learning Theory. This approach encourages learners to actively explore and apply general writing principles, thereby promoting a more independent and reflective learning process.

Implications for Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) under the theme of Cohesion and Coherence

The AI’s specific suggestion for enhancing cohesion contributes to perceived usefulness, a key factor in TAM. Users are likely to accept technology that provides actionable insights for improvement, enhancing their understanding of writing principles. The AI’s suggestion to follow general writing rules may contribute to perceived usefulness by providing general guidance.

Implications for Human-AI Interaction Theory under the theme of Cohesion and Coherence

The AI’s specific suggestion to improve cohesion contributes to a positive humanAI interaction. Clear feedback on the need for transitional elements encourages effective collaboration between the user and the AI, improving the overall learning experience. The AI’s suggestion to follow general writing rules can influence the human-AI interaction.

Table 5. Statements Related to the Feedback Under the Theme
of Overall Evaluation

R2Manual modification is not as efficient asAI, and capturing details and providing modificationmethods is not as comprehensive asAI.R3Theteacher,beingdirectlyinvolvedinourlearningprocess,hasacomprehensiveunderstanding of our individual capabilities.They are aware of our strengths,weaknesses,and areas that require improvement.This personalized feedback is invaluable as it is tailoredto our unique learning journey.R4Personally, the human feedback can better adapt to the different real-life situations sharedby the teacher and the students,while theAI feedback is more detailed in terms of languageskills. So from the perspective of improving language skills,AI feedback seems to be morehelpful.R5In comparison, theAI‘s feedbackwasvery thorough, covering a comprehensive evaluation ofvarious aspects ofwriting. But it‘s important to note that, although theAI‘s feedback includedsome examples, specific errorswere not mentioned directly.
R7AI feedback, I think it is more detailed. Each part of the commentwill post an example forreaders to comprehend.R8AI feedbackwill be better and more complete than the teacher‘s handwritten feedback.Even though both the manual feedback and theAI‘s feedback evaluate the essay in each ofthe four different elements, theAI‘s evaluation is more detailed.AI feedback may be moreobjective than human feedback.R9In my opinion, feedback fromAI is better than feedback from human teachers in this case,theAI‘s feedback is more detailed than the human teacher‘s feedback and provides somefeasible ideas for improvement. Secondly,AI‘s feedback is more objective and comprehensivethan human teachers‘feedback.R10The feedback given by theAI is more organized,with different summaries for each point,providing both the good and the bad points, aswell as giving changes to the sentences thatit thinks need to be changed.R11TheAI evaluation seems to be more specific and more personalized.This personalizedfeedbackcanbeimmenselyhelpfulformeasithighlightsspecificareasthatneedimprovement, helping me to understand my mistakes and make targeted revisions.R12The feedback given by teachers is more intuitive and general, and the feedback from theAIis more detailed andvaried.R13The difference between the teacher’s feedback on the paper andAI’s feedback is thatthe teacher’s feedback is more concise and provides a grade,while theAI further givessuggestions for revision.To sum up, the teacher’s feedback in Englishwriting is stillnecessary because it is more comprehensive, andAI can be used a complementary part.R14Overall, theAI‘s feedbackwas more objective,while the human feedbackwas more subjective.In addition, theAI‘s feedbackwas more detailed and gave suggestions for corrections,whereasthemanualfeedbackwasbriefer.However,themanualfeedbackreflectstheteacher‘s degree of affirmation of the homework and can encourage students to completethe homework better.Therefore, I think it is better to evaluate our assignmentswith both theteacher‘s and theAI’s comments.R15AI feedback can‘t provide the emotional support or more in-depth guidance like a teachercan, but it has many advantages.AI feedback is more detailed, comprehensive and objective.

Implications for Constructivist Learning Theory under the theme of Overall Evaluation

The focus on capturing detail and providing comprehensive correction methods reflects an active learning process that encourages learners to engage with and understand the intricacies of writing improvement. The teacher’s direct involvement in the learning process, understanding of individual abilities, and personalized feedback supports Constructivist Learning Theory. This approach encourages learners to actively reflect on their strengths, weaknesses, and areas for improvement, promoting a personalized and dynamic learning journey. The recognition that human feedback is more adaptable to real-life situations is consistent with Constructivist Learning Theory. This suggests that human feedback to adapt to different learning contexts, fostering a dynamic and contextually relevant learning environment.

Implications for Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) under the theme of Overall Evaluation

The thoroughness of AI feedback, covering various aspects of writing, supports perceived usefulness, a key factor in TAM. The detailed nature of AI feedback, including examples for better understanding, contributes to perceived usefulness, supporting the principles of TAM. This suggests that the detailed feedback provided by AI is likely to be accepted and appreciated by users. The perception that AI feedback is more objective is consistent with TAM, as users are likely to accept technology that provides objective and detailed evaluations. The perception that AI provides more detailed feedback may positively influence users’ attitudes towards the technology. The preference for AI feedback due to its detail, objectivity, and comprehensiveness is in line with TAM principles. Users are more likely to accept technology that provides detailed and objective feedback, contributing to positive attitudes and perceptions of usefulness. The organized nature of AI feedback, with different summaries for each item, supports TAM by increasing the perceived usefulness of the technology. The systematic presentation of feedback contributes to a positive user experience.

Implications for Human-AI Interaction Theory under the theme of Overall Evaluation

The perception that AI assessment is more specific and personalized supports a positive human-AI interaction. Clear and personalized feedback promotes an effective collaboration between the user and the AI, contributing to a positive user experience. The perception that AI feedback is more detailed and varied is consistent with a positive human-AI interaction. This variety contributes to a dynamic and engaging interaction, improving the overall user experience. Recognizing that teacher feedback is more concise and provides a grade, while AI provides suggestions for revision, supports a collaborative human-AI interaction. This recognizes the complementary roles of both the teacher and AI in providing comprehensive feedback. The recognition that AI feedback is more objective and detailed, while human feedback reflects affirmation and encouragement, suggests a harmonious human-AI interaction. The combination of objective AI assessments and human encouragement contributes to a positive and balanced learning environment. Recognizing that AI feedback lacks emotional support but has advantages in detail, comprehensiveness, and objectivity supports a nuanced human-AI interaction. This recognition of the strengths and limitations of both human and AI feedback contributes to an informed and balanced approach.

6. Discussion

This study analyzed the efficacy of artificial intelligence automated writing feedback tools in comparison to human teacher’s feedback for enhancing the writing skills of English Language Learners. This was a comparative study and the outcomes of two feedback types were compared and discussed based on learners’ writing assignments. This discussion was centered around key findings from recent academic articles, exploring the implications for various learning theories, technology acceptance, and human-AI interaction.

The study’s findings supported Taşkıran et al. (2024) emphasis on the positive impact of AF on writing competence, motivation and the learning environment. Their findings emphasized AF’s positive impact on writing competence, motivation, and the learning environment. These results were in line with Constructivist Learning Theory, which highlights the importance of active engagement and knowledge construction. The clear communication and detailed suggestions facilitate a collaborative and effective interaction between learners and AI systems. Similarly, Liu et al. (2023) proposed an AI-supported English writing approach, based on reflective teaching mechanisms, resulting in significant improvements in learners’ writing performance, self-efficacy, and self-regulated learning. These findings were consistent with the present study, which highlighted the importance of Constructivist Learning Theory in emphasizing learners’ active participation in shaping their understanding. Both studies demonstrated the positive impact of AI-supported writing tools on self-efficacy and self-regulated learning. Learners were likely to accept and engage with these tools due to the AI’s role in reducing cognitive load and enhancing self-regulated learning. This fosters a cooperative and adaptive relationship between learners and AI systems, resulting in a more effective interaction.

The results of Bewersdoff et al. (2023) identified fundamental student errors, providing a basis for personalized feedback. This finding was consistent with the present study and Constructivist Learning Theory as the AI can pinpoint learners’errors in improving their writing skills. In terms of TAM, the accurate identification of errors contributed to the perceived usefulness of the AI system. The AI’s precise error identification fostered a positive and effective interaction, aligning with Human-AI Interaction Theory. Furthermore, Fawaz (2023) investigated Wordtune’s impact on students’ writing and revealed significant improvements in the experimental group’s writing compared to the control group. This finding was consistent with Constructivist Learning Theory and the present study’s result, which highlighted the importance of active engagement and knowledge construction. The positive impact of Wordtune suggested that learners are actively shaping their understanding of effective writing through the use of AI tools. TAM was supported by the perceived effectiveness of Wordtune. The technology’s capacity to enhance writing skills contributed to its perceived usefulness, aligning with TAM principles. Using Wordtune has a positive impact on writing skills, demonstrating that a cooperative and adaptive relationship between students and AI systems.

Shum et al. (2023) analyzed the use of open AF tools by teachers through the lens of teacher feedback literacy and they concluded that effective use of open AF tools aligned with the results of this study. Both studies emphasized the active engagement of teachers in shaping their understanding of effective feedback practices through the use of AI tools. From a TAM perspective, teachers’ positive experiences and competencies with AI tools supported the technology’s acceptance and utilization. The effective use of open AF tools demonstrated a cooperative and adaptive relationship between teachers and AI systems, resulting in more effective interaction. Moreover, the study conducted by Yang et al. (2023) on EFL students’ interactions with Pigai, the largest AI-programmed Automated Writing Evaluation (AWE) system in China, supported the findings of this research, emphasizing learners’ active engagement in enhancing their language skills in terms of error corrective feedback and providing rich linguistic resources. In terms of TAM, EFL students were likely to accept technology that aided in error correction and provided valuable resources for language improvement. The provision of error corrective feedback and rich linguistic resources promotes cooperative and effective interaction between EFL students and AI systems.

On the other hand, Chen (2022) investigated the feedback and effect of Aim Writing on college students’ writing in China. The study found that Aim Writing’s performance was insufficient, indicating a need for a hybrid model that incorporates both Automated Essay Scoring (AES) and instructor feedback. This aligned with the findings of this study, which emphasizes the adaptive and reflective nature of learning.

7. Conclusion

This study focused on the comparative analysis of artificial intelligence (AI) automated writing feedback tools and human teacher feedback, aiming to understand their performances in developing the writing skills of English Language Learners. The study explored various dimensions, including content, vocabulary, grammar, cohesion and coherence, and overall evaluation and connecting the findings to prominent learning theories, technology acceptance models, and human-AI interaction theories.

The implications drawn from the data analysis provided valuable insights into the alignment of AI feedback with educational theories. In terms of Constructivist Learning Theory, AI feedback promoted active engagement, reflective learning, and knowledge construction across topics. TAM principles were supported by the perceived usefulness of AI in providing specific and detailed feedback, which contributed to users’ positive attitudes and intentions to use the technology. Human-AI Interaction Theory findings emphasized the clarity, collaboration, and adaptability of the interaction between users and AI systems, fostering a positive user experience.

The study acknowledged the limitations of AI feedback, such as the lack of emotional support and adaptability to diverse real-life situations. It also recognized the complementary role of human feedback, particularly in providing contextual guidance. The nuanced findings suggest a balanced approach that recognizes the strengths and limitations of both human and AI feedback, thereby contributing to a more informed and adaptive learning environment.

In conclusion, this research advances our understanding of the complex dynamics between AI-driven and human feedback in the context of language learning. The study’s findings provide a foundation for further exploration and encourage educators and researchers to consider the multiple implications of incorporating AI tools into writing instruction. As technology continues to evolve, adopting a collaborative and learner-centered approach, will be crucial in shaping the future of language education.

REFERENCES

BREY, P.; SØRAKER, J.H., 2009. Philosophy of computing and information technology. Philosophy of Technology and Engineering Sciences. pp.1341 – 1407.

BEWERSDORFF, A.; SEßLER, K.; BAUR, A.; KASNECI, E.; NERDEL, C., 2023. Assessing student errors in experimentation using artificial intelligence and large language models: A comparative study with human raters. Computers and Education: Artificial Intelligence. Available from: doi.org/10.1016/j.caeai.2023.100177.

CHEN, H.; PAN, J., 2022. Computer or human: a comparative study of automated evaluation scoring and instructors’ feedback on Chinese college students’ English writing. Asian-Pacific Journal of Second and Foreign Language Education, vol. 7, no. 34.

DAVIS, F. D., 1989. Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use, and User Acceptance of Information Technology. MIS Quarterly, vol. 3, no. 3, pp. 319 – 340.

FAWAZ, A. M., 2023. Investigating EFL students’ writing skills through Artificial Intelligence: Wordtune application as a tool. Journal of Language Teaching and Research, vol. 14, no. 5, pp. 1395 – 1404. DOI: https://doi.org/10.17507/jltr.1405.2.

FRAENKEL, J. W.; Wallen, N. E. & Hyun, H. H., 2012. How to design and Evaluate Research in Education. New York: Mc Graw Hill.

LIU, C.; JIERUI HOU; YUN-FANG TU; YOUMEI WANG; GWO-JEN HWANG., 2023. Incorporating a reflective thinking promoting mechanism into artificial intelligence supported English writing environments, Interactive Learning Environments, vol. 31, no. 9, pp. 5614 – 5632, DOI: 10.1080/10494820.2021.2012812.

LIM, F.V.; PHUA, J., 2019. Teaching writing with language feedback technology. Computers and Composition, no. 54.

NAZARI, N.; SHABBIR, M.S.; SETIAWAN, R., 2021. Application of Artificial Intelligence powered digital writing assistant in higher education: randomized controlled trial. Heliyon, vol. 1, no. 9. DOI:10.1016/j.heliyon.2021.e07014.

SHUM, S. B.; LISAANGELIQUE, L.; BOUD, D.; BEARMAN, M.; DAWSON, P, 2023. A comparative analysis of the skilled use of automated feedback tools through the lens of teacher feedback literacy. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, vol. 20, no. 1, DOI:10.1186/s41239-023-00410-9.

SUN, T., 2023. The Potential Use of Generative AI in ESL Writing Assessment: A Case Study of IELTS Writing Tasks. Irish Journal of Technology Enhanced Learning, vol. 7, no. 2.

SUHENDI, A.; PURWARNO., 2018. Constructivist Learning Theory: The Contribution to Foreign Language Learning and Teaching. 1st Annual International Conference on Language and Literature, KnE Social Sciences, pp. 87 – 95.

TAŞKIRAN, A.; YAZICI, M.; AYDIN, I.M., 2024. Contribution of automated feedback to the English writing competence of distance foreign language learners. E-Learning and Digital Media, vol. 21, no. 1, pp. 24 – 41.

TONCIC, J., 2020. Teachers, AI grammar checkers, and the newest literacies: Emending writing pedagogy and assessment. Digital Culture & Education, vol. 12, no. 1.

WANG, Z., 2022. Computer-assisted EFL writing and evaluations based on artificial intelligence: a case from a college reading and writing course. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 80 – 97.

YANG, H.; GAO, C.; SHEN, H., 2023. Learner interaction with, and response to, AI programmed automated writing evaluation feedback in EFL writing: An exploratory study. Education and Information Technologies, vol. 29, pp. 3837 – 3858.

2025 година
Книжка 9s
Книжка 9
DEVELOPMENT OF DEMOCRATIC CULTURE THROUGH CONTENTS ABOUT THE ROMA IN CLASSROOM TEACHING – STUDENTS’ PERCEPTION

Aleksandra Trbojević, Biljana Jeremić, Hadži Živorad Milenović, Bojan Lazić

Книжка 8
КАТЕГОРИАЛНИ ИЗМЕРЕНИЯ НА ИНФОРМАЦИОННО-КОМУНИКАЦИОННИТЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В ОБУЧЕНИЕТО НА ДЕЦА И УЧЕНИЦИ СЪС СОП

д.п.н Мира Цветкова-Арсова, Данка Щерева, Славина Лозанова, Маргарита Томова

Книжка 7
ВРЪЗКА НА СОЦИАЛНО-ЕМОЦИОНАЛНОТО С КОГНИТИВНОТО РАЗВИТИЕ В ПРИОБЩАВАЩА СРЕДА

Милен Замфиров, Маргарита Бакрачева, Емилия Евгениева

Книжка 6
КОГНИТИВНО РАЗВИТИЕ НА ДЕЦА И УЧЕНИЦИ, ОБХВАНАТИ В ПРИОБЩАВАЩОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Милен Замфиров, Емилия Евгениева, Маргарита Бакрачева

Книжка 5
COMPETENCE FOR SOCIAL PEDAGOGICAL PRACTICE: WHAT DO STUDENTS TELL US?

Maya Tcholakova, Marina Pironkova, Aleksandar Ranev, Yana Staneva

MULTIMODAL COMMUNICATION IN PHYSICAL EDUCATION CLASSES

Cristiana Lucretia Pop, Cristina Filip

Книжка 4s
GAMES IN FUNCTION OF DEVELOPMENT OF MULTIPLICATION SKILLS

Dasare Sylejmani, Vesna Makashevska, Jasmina Jovanovska

Книжка 4
ИЗПОЛЗВАНЕ НА СИСТЕМИТЕ ЗА УПРАВЛЕНИЕ НА ОБУЧЕНИЕТО В КОНТЕКСТА НА ИНТЕРАКТИВНОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Силвия Парушева, Борис Банков, Гергана Касабова, Петя Страшимирова

MILITARY AND SOCIAL THREATS AS DETERMINANTS OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF CONTEMPORARY UKRAINIAN HIGHER EDUCATION

Mykola Pantiuk, Tetiana Pantiuk, Nataliia Bakhmat, Olena Nevmerzhytska, Svitlana Ivakh

STEM ОБУЧЕНИЕ НА СТУДЕНТИ ПЕДАГОЗИ В ТРАНСДИСЦИПЛИНАРНА ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛНА СРЕДА

Любен Витанов, Николай Цанев, Людмила Зафирова, Гергана Христова, Катерина Динкова, Калина Георгиева, Жорж Кюшев, Здравка Савчева

ИЗСЛЕДВАНЕ И АНАЛИЗ НА НАГЛАСИТЕ НА СТУДЕНТИТЕ ПРИ ИЗПОЛЗВАНЕ НА ГЕНЕРАТИВЕН ИНСТРУМЕНТ НА ИЗКУСТВЕН ИНТЕЛЕКТ

Николай Янев, Иглика Гетова, Теодора Христова, Ива Костадинова, Георги Димитров

Книжка 3
ДРУГИЯТ КАТО ЦЕННОСТ В УЧИЛИЩЕ

Александър Кръстев

Книжка 2
ASSESSMENTS OF TEACHERS AND PARENTS OF CHILDREN WITH DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES ON INCLUSION IN PRE-SCHOOL INSTITUTIONS

Zagorka Markov, Hadzi Zivorad Milenovic, Biljana Jeremic, Radmila Zecevic, Milica Pavlovic

Книжка 1s
ПРИЛОЖЕНИЕ НА СРЕДСТВАТА ЗА ДОПЪЛВАЩА И АЛТЕРНАТИВНА КОМУНИКАЦИЯ В ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛНИТЕ ИНСТИТУЦИИ В БЪЛГАРИЯ

. Неда Балканска, . Анна Трошева-Асенова, . Пенка Шапкова, Снежина Михайлова

USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN FOREIGN LANGUAGE TEACHING

Ekaterina Sofronieva, Christina Beleva, Galina Georgieva

Книжка 1
Скъпи читатели, автори, приятели на списание „Педагогика“,

В началото на 2025 година в първия брой на нашето списание „Педагогика“ бих искала от името на редакционната колегия и от мое име да Ви пожелая здраве, творческо вдъхновение и професионално удовлетворение от прино- са Ви към педагогическата наука и практика! Вярвам и се надявам, че списание „Педагоги- ка“ ще продължи да осигурява платформа за научен, обективен и откровен диалог, базиран на резултати от научни изследвания, за насто- ящето и бъдещето на обучението и образова- н

2024 година
Книжка 9s
Книжка 9
ANALYSIS AND IMPROVEMENT OF VIDEO LEARNING RESOURCES IN SMALL-SCALE LEARNING SCENARIOS

César Córcoles, Laia Blasco-Soplon, Germán Cobo Rodríguez, Ana-Elena Guerrero-Roldán

Книжка 8
АНГАЖИРАНОСТ КЪМ УЧЕНЕ ЧРЕЗ ИЗПОЛЗВАНЕ НА СМАРТ ТЕХНОЛОГИИТЕ В ОБРАЗОВАНИЕТО

Кирилка Тагарева, Дора Левтерова-Гаджалова, Ваня Сивакова

Книжка 7
Книжка 6
Книжка 5s
ПРЕДИЗВИКАТЕЛСТВАТА НА СТАЖАНТСКАТА ПРАКТИКА ПРЕД СТУДЕНТИ – БЪДЕЩИ УЧИТЕЛИ

Илиана Петкова, Марияна Илиева, Владислава Станоева, Георги Чавдаров

Книжка 5
FEATURES OF SPEECH COMPREHENSION TRAINING OF CHILDREN WITH AUTISM SPECTRUM DISORDERS

Maryna Branytska, Svitlana Myronova, Svitlana Mykhalska

OVERVIEW OF THE STEM EDUCATION IN ISRAEL

Aharon Goldreich, Elena Karashtranova

Книжка 4
НАГЛАСИ НА СТУДЕНТИТЕ КЪМ СМАРТ ТЕХНОЛОГИИТЕ В ОБРАЗОВАНИЕТО

Дора Левтерова-Гаджалова, Кирилка Тагарева, Ваня Сивакова

PROFESSIONAL SUPPORT FOR YOUNG RESEARCHERS

Emina Vukašinović, Marija Veselinović, Milan Milikić

РОБОТИТЕ В ОБУЧЕНИЕТО – ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛНА STEAM ИГРА

Мария Желязкова, Михаил Кожухаров, Даниела Кожухарова

Книжка 3s
Книжка 3
ATTITUDES AND EXPERIENCES OF THE PRESCHOOL TEACHERS IN THE APPLICATION OF DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES IN ENVIRONMENTAL EDUCATION

Nataša Branković, Gordana Kozoderović, Biljana Jeremić, Danijela Petrović, Bojan Lazić, Slavica Karanović

ДИГИТАЛНИ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В ПОДКРЕПА НА УЧЕНЕТО

Стоянка Георгиева-Лазарова, Лъчезар Лазаров

PREPARATION OF FUTURE TEACHERS FOR ORGANISING A HEALTH-PRESERVING INCLUSIVE SPACE IN EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS

Nadiya Skotna, Tetiana Nadimyanova, Anna Fedorovych, Myroslava Sosiak, Oksana Yatsiv

Книжка 2s
Книжка 2
ОТ РИСУНКА – КЪМ СНИМКА

Камен Теофилов

Книжка 1s
Книжка 1
„ВТОРОТО“ БЪЛГАРСКО УЧИЛИЩЕ. ГЕНЕЗИСЪТ

Пенка Цонева, Бистра Мизова

2023 година
Книжка 9
EXPLORING THE NARRATIVE IDENTITY OF HUNGARIAN TEACHERS IN SLOVAKIA

Patrik Baka, Terézia Stredl, Kinga Horváth, Zsuzsanna Huszár, Melinda Nagy, Péter Tóth, András Németh

Книжка 8
A QUALITY “ONLINE” TEACHER – WHAT DO STUDENTS APPRECIATE AND VALUE IN TEACHERS DURING DISTANCE LEARNING?

Irena Golubović-Ilić, Ivana Ćirković-Miladinović, Nataša Vukićević

SUPPORT FOR THE INCLUSION OF ROMA CHILDREN THROUGH THE PROJECT TEACHING MODEL

Biljana Jeremić, Aleksandra Trbojević, Bojan Lazić, Gordana Kozoderović

TREND ANALYSIS OF PROFESSIONAL COMPETENCES OF SPORTS TEACHERS AND COACHES

Sergejs Capulis, Valerijs Dombrovskis, Svetlana Guseva, Alona Korniseva

Книжка 7
ЦЕННОСТЕН ПРОФИЛ НА УЧИТЕЛИТЕ В НАЦИОНАЛЕН КОНТЕКСТ

Цветан Давидков, Силвия Цветанска

Книжка 6s
MODELLING OF MARITIME CYBER SECURITY EDUCATION AND TRAINING

Gizem Kayisoglu, Pelin Bolat, Emre Duzenli

INTRODUCING THE USE OF CASE STUDIES METHODOLOGY IN TRAINING FOR SOFT SKILLS IN MARITIME UNIVERSITIES. THE ISOL-MET PROGRAM

Maria Lekakou, Helen Iakovaki, Dimitris Vintzilaios, Markella Gota, Giorgos Georgoulis, Thalia Vintzilaiou

THE ROLE OF MARITIME EDUCATION IN DIGITALIZATION

Kamelia Narleva, Yana Gancheva

Книжка 6
С МИСИЯ ЗА НАЦИОНАЛНА И КУЛТУРНА ИНДИВИДУАЛНОСТ

Надежда Кръстева, Йордан Колев

Книжка 5s
PREFACE

Nikola Vaptsarov Naval Academy is the oldest technical educational institution in Bulgaria. The Naval Academy is one of the symbols of Varna and Bulgaria in the world maritime community. Its history and achievements establish it as the most prestigious center for training of maritime specialists. At present, the Naval Academy trains specialists for the Navy and for the merchant marine in all areas of maritime life. Research and development conducted at the Naval Academy in Varna

A FAIR CONCERN ABOUT ECDIS

Nikolay Sozonov, Dilyan Dimitranov

DATA-DRIVEN LEARNING APPROACH TO MARITIME ENGLISH

Jana Kegalj, Mirjana Borucinsky, Sandra Tominac Coslovich

DEVELOPING CRITICAL THINKING SKILLS THROUGH THE “CASE STUDY” TEACHING METHOD IN MARITIME ENGLISH LANGUAGE TEACHING (MELT)

Tamila Mikeladze, Svetlana Rodinadze, Zurab Bezhanovi, Kristine Zarbazoia, Medea Abashidze, Kristine Iakobadze

MAXIMIZING STUDENTS’ LEARNING IN MARITIME ENGLISH ONLINE COURSE

Valentyna Kudryavtseva, Svitlana Barsuk, Olena Frolova

Книжка 5
Книжка 4s
Книжка 4
Книжка 3s
СПИРАЛАТА ОБЩЕСТВО – ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Иванка Шивачева-Пинеда

Книжка 3
ПРОЕКТНО БАЗИРАНО ОБУЧЕНИЕ ЗА СОЦИАЛНО-ЕМОЦИОНАЛНИ И ТЕХНОЛОГИЧНИ УМЕНИЯ ЧРЕЗ ПРОГРАМАТА „УМЕНИЯ ЗА ИНОВАЦИИ“

Галин Цоков, Александър Ангелов, Йоанна Минчева, Рени Димова, Мария Цакова

МЕДИЙНАТА ГРАМОТНОСТ И УЧИТЕЛИТЕ

Светла Цанкова, Стела Ангова, Мария Николова, Иван Вълчанов, Илия Вълков, Георги Минев

Книжка 2
INTONATION AND CHILDREN WITH EMOTIONAL AND BEHAVIORAL PROBLEMS

Katerina Zlatkova-Doncheva, Vladislav Marinov

Книжка 1
2022 година
Книжка 9
ТРАНСГРЕСИВНО-СИНЕРГИЧНО КАРИЕРНО РАЗВИТИЕ В „НЕФОРМАЛНО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ“ В УНИВЕРСИТЕТА

д.п.н Яна Рашева-Мерджанова, Моника Богданова, Илиана Петкова

Книжка 8
INTEGRATING INTERCULTURAL EDUCATION IN THE PRIMARY SCHOOL CURRICULUM

Bujar Adili, Sonja Petrovska, Gzim Xhambazi

НАГЛАСИ НА БЪДЕЩИТЕ ДЕТСКИ УЧИТЕЛИ КЪМ STEM ПОДХОДА

Наталия Павлова, Михаела Тончева

Книжка 7
НАЦИОНАЛНАТА ИДЕЯ НА ПАИСИЙ ХИЛЕНДАРСКИ

Йордан Колев, Надежда Кръстева

Книжка 6
Книжка 5
ИВАН Д. ШИШМАНОВ – ЕВРОПЕИЗИРАНИЯТ БЪЛГАРИН

Надежда Кръстева, Йордан Колев

THE TECHNOLOGY OF DEVELOPMENT OF COMMUNICATIVE CULTURE OF ELEMENTARY SCHOOL TEACHERS

Mariia Oliiar, Nataliia Blahun, Halyna Bilavych, Nataliia Bakhmat, Tetyana Pantyuk

Книжка 4
TEACHERS’ATTITUDES BOUT TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS

Aleksandra Mihajlović, Emina Kopas-Vukašinović, Vladimir Stanojević

EDUCATION 4.0 – THE CHANGE OF HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS AND THE LABOUR MARKET

Gergana Dimitrova, Blaga Madzhurova, Stefan Raychev, Dobrinka Stoyanova

Книжка 3s
DISTANCE LEARNING IN THE CONTEXT OF THE COVID-19 PANDEMICS

Baktybek Keldibekov, Shailoobek Karagulov

DIGITAL UNIVERSITIES: FEATURES AND KEY CHARACTERISTICS

Marina Skiba, Maktagali Bektemessov, Alma Turganbayeva

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
TWO-TIER MODEL OF TRAINING FUTURE TEACHERS FOR COACHING AT OUT-OF-SCHOOL INSTITUTIONS

Borys Savchuk, Tetyana Pantyuk, Natalia Sultanova, Halyna Bilavych, Mykola Pantyuk

Книжка 1
2021 година
Книжка 9
ИЗСЛЕДВАНЕ НА ВЗАИМОДЕЙСТВИЕТО МЕЖДУ ФОРМАЛНОТО И НЕФОРМАЛНОТО ЗДРАВНО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Доц. д-р Вержиния Боянова Гл. ас. д-р Константин Теодосиев Гл. ас. д-р Берджухи Йорданова

FORMATION OF PROFESSIONAL COMPETENCE OF ASSISTANT TEACHER OF INCLUSIVE EDUCATION IN SECONDARY EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS

Prof. Dr. Vladyslava Liubarets, Prof. Dr. Nataliia Bakhmat, Prof. Dr. Olena Matviienko, Oksana Tsykhmeistruk, Inna Feltsan

Книжка 8
ОТНОСНО ЗАДЪЛЖИТЕЛНОСТТА НА ПРЕДУЧИЛИЩНОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ – РЕЗУЛТАТИ ОТ ЕДНО ИЗСЛЕДВАНЕ

Проф. д-р Маргарита Колева, доц. д-р Блага Джорова, д-р Ева Жечева

INFLUENCE OF PSYCHOLOGICAL AND PEDAGOGICAL FEATURES OF STUDENTS ON THEIR ACTIVITY IN SELF-EDUCATION

Dr. Iryna Sereda, Assoc. Prof. Dr. Svitlana Karskanova, Assoc. Prof.

CENTRALISATION AND DECENTRALISATION IN HIGHER EDUCATION: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF HUNGARY AND GERMANY

Carla Liege Rodrigues Pimenta, Prof. Dr. Zolt†n R–nay, Prof. Dr. Andr†s Nmet

ЗА ПРИОБЩАВАНЕТО, ОБУЧЕНИЕТО И РАЗВИТИЕТО НА ДЕЦА И УЧЕНИЦИ С ИНТЕЛЕКТУАЛНИ ЗАТРУДНЕНИЯ

Златкова-Дончева, К. (2021). Приобщаване, обучение и развитие на деца и ученици с интелектуални затруднения. Бургас: Либра СКОРП, ISBN 978-954-471-705-6

Книжка 7s
CONCEPT OF PRESENT PRACTICE IN CHOOSING OF OPTIMAL NUMBER OF TUGS

Rino Bošnjak, Zvonimir Lušić , Filip Bojić, Dario Medić

S-101 CHARTS, DATABASE TABLES FOR S-101 CHARTS, AUTONOMOUS VESSEL

Vladimir Brozović, Danko Kezić, Rino Bošnjak, Filip Bojić

INFLUENCE OF HYDRO-METEOROLOGICAL ELEMENTS ON THE SHIP MANOEUVRING IN THE CITY PORT OF SPLIT

Zvonimir Lušić , Nenad Leder, Danijel Pušić, Rino Bošnjak

MEETING SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS – EXPERIENCE FROM THE LARGEST SHIPPING COMPANIES

Katarina Balić , Helena Ukić Boljat, Gorana Jelić Mrčelić, Merica Slišković

OPTIMISING THE REFERENCE POINT WITHIN A JOURNAL BEARING USING LASER ALIGNMENT

Ty Aaron Smith , Guixin Fan , Natalia Nikolova , Kiril Tenekedjiev

REVIEW OF THE CURRENT INCREASE OF NOISE UNIT COST VALUES IN TRANSPORT

Luka Vukić , Ivan Peronja , Mihaela Bukljaš , Alen Jugović

TARGET DETECTION FOR VISUAL COLLISION AVOIDANCE SYSTEM

Miro Petković, Danko Kezić, Igor Vujović, Ivan Pavić

NEW RESULTS FOR TEACHING SHIP HANDLING USING FAST TIME SIMULATION

Knud Benedict , MichŽle Schaub , Michael Baldauf , Michael Gluch , Matthias Kirchhoff , Caspar Krüger

POTENTIAL BENEFITS OF ELECTRICALY DRIVEN FERRY, CASE STUDY

Tina Perić, Ladislav Stazić, Karlo Bratić

SITUATIONAL AWARENESS – KEY SAFETY FACTOR FOR THE OFFICER OF THE WATCH

Hrvoje Jaram, Pero Vidan, Srđan Vukša, Ivan Pavić

Книжка 7
INCLUSIVE INTELLIGENCE

Dr. Aleksandar Krastev, Assist. Prof.

EDUCATION OF MORAL CULTURE OF STUDENT YOUTH IN THE CONDITIONS OF POLYCULTURAL SPACE

Dr. Natalia Bondarenko, Assoc. Prof. Yevhen Rozdymakha Dr. Lyudmila Oderiy, Assoc. Prof. Dr. Anatoly Rozdymakha, Assoc. Prof. Dilyana Arsova, PhD student

PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT IN KOSOVO – RESEARCH OF TRAINING PROGRAMS AND TESTS

Bekim Samadraxha, Veton Alihajdari, Besim Mustafa, Ramë Likaj

Книжка 6s
EVALUATION OF CRUISER TRAFFIC VARIABLES IN SEAPORTS OF THE REPUBLIC OF CROATIA

Maja Račić, Katarina Balić, Mira Pavlinović, Antonija Mišura

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE CONTRACTS FOR MARITIME TRANSPORT SERVICES. CHAIN OF CHARTER PARTIES

Svetlana Dimitrakieva, Ognyan Kostadinov, Christiana Atanasova

THE LIGHTSHIP MASS CALCULATION MODEL OF A MERCHANT SHIP BY EMPIRICAL METHODS

Vedran Slapničar , Katarina Zadro , Viktor Ložar , Ivo Ćatipović

ON EDUCATION AND TRAINING IN MARITIME COMMUNICATIONS AND THE GMDSS DURING THE COVID-19

Chavdar Alexandrov, Grozdyu Grozev, Georgi Dimitrov, Avgustin Hristov

AIR POLLUTANT EMISSION MEASUREMENT

Nikola Račić, Branko Lalić, Ivan Komar, Frane Vidović, Ladislav Stazić

ASSESSMENT OF LNG BUNKERING ACCIDENTS

Peter Vidmar, Andrej Androjna

EGR OPERATION INFLUENCE ON THE MARINE ENGINE EFFICIENCY

Delyan Hristov, Ivan Ivanov, Dimitar Popov

THE MEASUREMENT OF EXHAUST GAS EMISSIONS BY TESTO 350 MARITIME – EXHAUST GAS ANALYZER

Bruna Bacalja, Maja Krčum, Tomislav Peša, Marko Zubčić

PROPELLER LOAD MODELLING IN THE CALCULATIONS OF MARINE SHAFTING TORSIONAL VIBRATIONS

Nenad Vulić, Karlo Bratić, Branko Lalić, Ladislav Stazić

MODELING OF THE DEPENDENCE OF CO

Hristo Hristov, Ivailo Bakalov, Bogdan Shopov, Dobromir Yovkov

TECHNICAL DIAGNOSTICS OF MARINE EQUIPMENT WITH PSEUDO-DISCRETE FEATURES

Guixin Fan , Natalia Nikolova , Ty Smith , Kiril Tenekedjiev

CONTRIBUTION TO THE REDUCTION OF THE SHIP’S SWITCHBOARD BY APPLYING SENSOR TECHNOLOGY

Nediljko Kaštelan, Marko Zubčić, Maja Krčum, Miro Petković

THE STAND FOR FIN DRIVES ENERGY TESTING

Andrzej Grządziela , Marcin Kluczyk , Tomislav Batur

INTRODUCTION OF 3D PRINTING INTO MARINE ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING EDUCATION – A CASE STUDY

Ivica Kuzmanić, Igor Vujović, Zlatan Kulenović, Miro Petković

SHIPYARD CRANE MODELING METHODS

Pawel Piskur, Piotr Szymak, Bartosz Larzewski

Книжка 6
TEACHERS' PERSPECTIVE ON THE EDUCATIONAL IMPLICATIONS OF ONLINE TEACHING

Dr. Julien-Ferencz Kiss, Prof. Dr. Florica Orțan, Dr. Laurențiu Mˆndrea

ПСИХОЛОГО-ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИ ПРАВИЛА, МОДЕЛИ НА ДОБРИ ПРАКТИКИ И ПРЕПОРЪКИ ПРИ РАБОТАТА И ОБУЧЕНИЕТО НА ДЕЦА И УЧЕНИЦИ С ПОВЕДЕНЧЕСКИ РАЗСТРОЙСТВА

Тричков, Ив., 2019. Психолого-педагогически правила, модели на добри прак- тики и препоръки при работата и обучението на деца и ученици

Книжка 5
ФИДАНА ДАСКАЛОВА ЗА ПЕДАГОГИКАТА

Маргарита Колева, Йордан Колев

ВОЕННОМОРСКОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ – ЕДИН РАЗЛИЧЕН ПОГЛЕД

Кожухаров, А. (2021). Личните академични документи на българската военна образователна система (1892 – 1946). Варна: ВВМУ, ISBN 978-619-7428-55-1

Книжка 4
Книжка 3
НЕВРОДИДАКТИКА

Наталия Витанова

ЗА АСИСТИРАЩИТЕ И ИНФОРМАЦИОННИТЕ ТЕХНОЛОГИИ В ОБРАЗОВАНИЕТО

Сивакова, В. (2020). Асистиращи и информационни технологии

Книжка 2
ОВЛАДЯВАНЕ НА КЛЮЧОВИ КОМПЕТЕНЦИИ ПРИ ОРИЕНТИРАНЕ В СВЕТА

Стоянова, М. (2019). Овладяване на ключови компетенции при ориентиране в света. София: Авангард принт, ISBN 978-954-337-398-7 374

Книжка 1
BULGARIAN SCHOOL – SHOWCASE OF IDENTITY

Veska Gyuviyska, Nikolay Tsankov

ЗА ИЗБОРА НА УЧЕБЕН КОМПЛЕКТ ПО БЪЛГАРСКИ ЕЗИК И ЛИТЕРАТУРА В НАЧАЛЕН ЕТАП. И ЗА ОБУЧЕНИЕТО

Георгиева, А. (2020). Съвременни проекции на обучението по български език

КОНТРОЛ НА СТРЕСА. ПСИХОЛОГИЧЕСКИ И УПРАВЛЕНСКИ РАКУРСИ

Стоянов, В. (2020). Управление на стреса в организацията. Психологически и управленски ракурси. 198 cтр., Варна: Стено, ISBN 978-619-241-119-0

2020 година
Книжка 9
Книжка 8
EDUCATIONAL REASONS FOR EARLY SCHOOL DROP-OUT

Maria Teneva, Zlatka Zhelyazkova

Книжка 7s
TEACHING CHALLENGES IN SPORTS EDUCATION DURING THE PANDEMIC COVID-19

Evelina Savcheva, Galina Domuschieva-Rogleva

THE DIFFERENCES IN STUDENTS’ ATTITUDES ABOUT ONLINE TEACHING DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Aleksić Veljković Aleksandra , Slađana Stanković , Irena Golubović-Ilić , Katarina Herodek

ONLINE EDUCATION DURING PANDEMIC, ACCORDING TO STUDENTS FROM TWO BULGARIAN UNIVERSITIES

Antoaneta Getova¹ , Eleonora Mileva² , Boryana Angelova-Igova²

Книжка 7
ПОДГОТОВКАТА НА ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИ КАДРИ ЗА ПРЕДУЧИЛИЩНИТЕ ВЪЗПИТАТЕЛНИ ЗАВЕДЕНИЯ ПРЕЗ ПЕРИОДА 1944 – 1991 ГОДИНА

Въчева, С. (2019). Подготовката на педагогически кадри за предучилищните възпитателни заведения през периода

ПАЗАРНИ МЕХАНИЗМИ В УЧИЛИЩНОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ. ТЕОРЕТИКО-ПРИЛОЖНИ ВЪПРОСИ

Първанова, Й. (2020) Пазарни механизми в училищното образование. Теоретико-приложни въпроси. София: Колбис, ISBN 978-619-7284-35-5

Книжка 6
TEACHERS ATTITUDES ABOUT INTEGRATED APPROACH IN TEACHING

Emina Kopas-Vukašinović, Aleksandra Mihajlović, Olivera Cekić-Jovanović

Книжка 5
КОНЦЕПТУАЛНИ МОДЕЛИ ЗА РАЗРАБОТВАНЕ НА ПОЗНАВАТЕЛНИ ОНЛАЙН ИГРИ В ОБЛАСТТА НА КУЛТУРНОТО НАСЛЕДСТВО

Детелин Лучев, Десислава Панева-Мариновa, Радослав Павлов Гита Сенка Лилия Павлова

ТАЛАНТЛИВ ПЕДАГОГ И КУЛТУРЕН ДЕЕЦ

Севда Чобанова, Любен Десев

Книжка 4
A CONTINUUM OF APPROACHES TO SCHOOL INSPECTIONS: CASES FROM EUROPE

Rossitsa Simeonova, Yonka Parvanova Martin Brown, Sarah Gardezi, Joe O’Hara, Gerry McNamara Laura del Castillo Blanco Zacharoula Kechri, Eleni Beniata

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
Книжка 1
2019 година
Книжка 9
Книжка 8
ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ НА БЪДЕЩЕТО

Наталия Витанова

Книжка 7
МОДЕЛ НА РАБОТА В ИНТЕРКУЛТУРНА СРЕДА

(Научноизследователска саморефлексия)

RISK FACTORS FOR EARLY SCHOOL LEAVING IN BULGARIA

Elena Lavrentsova, Petar Valkov

ПРИНОСИ НА ЕЛКА ПЕТРОВА ЗА БЪЛГАРСКОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

(100 години от рождението на проф. д.п.н. Елка Петрова – 27.10.1919 – 21.12.2012)

НАСОКИ ЗА ПРИОБЩАВАНЕ НА МАРГИНАЛНИ СЕМЕЙНИ ОБЩНОСТИ В ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛНИТЕ ИНСТИТУЦИИ

Нунев, Й. (2019). Насоки за приобщаване на маргинални семейни общности в образователните институции. Велико Търново: Св. св. Кирил и Методий, ISBN 978-619-208-186-7

Книжка 6
ДИОФАНТОВИ УРАВНЕНИЯ И СИСТЕМИ ДИОФАНТОВИ УРАВНЕНИЯ – ТЕОРЕТИЧНИ АСПЕКТИ И МЕТОДИЧЕСКА ПРОЕКЦИЯ В НАЧАЛНИЯ ЕТАП НА ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ

Владимира Ангелова. (2018). Диофантови уравнения и системи диофантови уравнения – теоретични аспекти и методическа проекция в начален етап на образование. Пловдив: Паисий Хилендарски, ISBN 978-619-202-394-2

ЕДНА НОВА КНИГА ЗА ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИТЕ УМЕНИЯ НА УЧИТЕЛИТЕ

Николай Колишев. (2018). Теория на педагогическите умения на учителите. София: Захарий Стоянов, ISBN: 9789540912066

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
ПРИЛОЖЕНИЕ НА ИЗСЛЕДОВАТЕЛСКИЯ ПОДХОД ПРИ ОБУЧЕНИЕ НА СТУДЕНТИ ПЕДАГОЗИ

(върху примера на обучение по академичната дисциплина „Съвременни аспекти на гражданското образование“ на студенти педагози)

LEARNING MATURITY

Alina G“mbuță Daniela-Carmen Berințan Marijana Mikulandra Krzysztof Kij Katja Sivka

Книжка 2
ДЕТЕТО И ПЕДАГОГИКАТА

Рашева-Мерджанова, Ян., Петкова, Ил. & Господинов, Вл. (съст.). (2018). Детето и педагогиката. София: Просвета, ISBN 978-954-01-3806-0

Книжка 1
УВАЖАЕМИ КОЛЕГИ,

Редакционната колегия на списание „Педаго- гика“ ви честити Новата 2019 година! Пожела- ваме ви от сърце тя да бъде щастлива, успешна и благословена! През отминалата юбилейна 2018 г. публику- вахме редица стойностни материали на универ- ситетски преподаватели, учители, разнородни специалисти, работещи в сферата на образова- нието, докторанти. Отбелязани бяха поредица от тематични конференции и юбилейни празни- ци. Получихме и международно признание чрез включването на списанието

УЧЕНИЧЕСКО САМОУПРАВЛЕНИЕ

Желязкова-Тея, Т. & Банчева, М. (2018). Ученическото самоуправление. София: Аз-буки. ISBN: 978-619-7065-20-6

2018 година
Книжка 9
ПРАВАТА НА ДЕТЕТО ПРЕЗ ПОГЛЕДА НА СТУДЕНТИ ПЕДАГОЗИ

Йорданка Николова, Даниела Рачева

Книжка 8
СПОДЕЛЕНО МНЕНИЕ

Николова, М. & Михалева, Б. (2018). С увереност срещу агресията и кон-

Книжка 7
РАДОСТТА ОТ ОБЩУВАНЕТО НА ЧУЖД ЕЗИК В ДЕТСТВОТО

Екатерина Софрониева, Христина Белева

НОВО ТЕОРЕТИКО-ПРАКТИЧЕСКО ИЗСЛЕДВАНЕ НА ДЕТСКОТО ТВОРЧЕСТВО

Енгелс-Критидис, Р. (2018). Децата и творчеството. Юбилеен сборник в чест

ПРОФ. Д-Р ЕЛЕНА РУСИНОВА-БАХУДЕЙЛА

Розалина Енгелс-Критидис

Книжка 6
ПОЗИТИВНА УЧЕБНА СРЕДА

Валентина Шарланова

SENIOR CITIZENS’ EXISTENTIAL NEEDS AND EDUCATION FOR THE MEANING OF LIFE

Joanna Łukasik, Norbert Pikuła, Katarzyna Jagielska

Книжка 5
ПЛАНОМЕРНО ПСИХИЧЕСКО РАЗВИТИЕ

(По случай 115 г. от рождението на П.Я. Галперин)

ПАРАДИГМАТА СЕМИОТИКА – ЕЗИК – ДЕТЕ ПРИ 6 – 7-ГОДИШНИТЕ

Жоржетина Атанасова, Любимка Габрова

ПАРАРОДИТЕЛСКАТА ГРИЖА ВЪВ ФОКУСА НА ЕДИН СОЦИАЛНОПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИ АНАЛИЗ

Ковачка, Ю. (2017). Социалнопедагогически проблеми при деца с парародителска грижа. Благоевград: УИ „Неофит Рилски“, 144 стр. ISBN: 9789540001340

Книжка 4
ДЕТСКИ КОНФЕРЕНЦИИ

Боряна Иванова

СТЕРЕОТИПИЗАЦИЯ НА ЕТНИЧЕСКИТЕ ВЗАИМООТНОШЕНИЯ ПРИ СЪВРЕМЕННИТЕ МЛАДИ БЪЛГАРИ

Зорница Ганева. (2017). Стереотипизация на етническите взаимоотношения при съвременните млади българи. София: Елестра. ISBN 978-619-7292-03-9

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
СЪВРЕМЕННИ МЕТАМОРФОЗИ НА ВЗАИМООТНОШЕНИЯТА В ДЕТСКАТА ГРУПА

Веселина Иванова, Виолета Кърцелянска-Станчева

SCHOOLS AND UNIVERSITIES AS SOCIAL INSTITUTIONS

Emilj Sulejmani Shikjerije Sulejmani

ОТНОСНО УСЕТА ЗА БРОЕНЕ

Петър Петров, Мима Трифонова

Книжка 1
УВАЖАЕМИ КОЛЕГИ И ПРИЯТЕЛИ,

Редакционната колегия на сп.„Педагогика“ Ви честити Новата 2018 г. Пожелаваме ви тя да бъде здрава, щедра и благословена! Тази година списанието чества своя юбилей – 90 години от неговото публикуване за първи път през 1928 г. с името „Народна просвета“. От деня на създаване до сега, то отразява актуал- ните проблеми на педагогическата наука и прак- тика и остава верен спътник на хиляди научни работници, учители, докторанти. Вярваме, че силата на творческата ни енергия ще пом

ДОБРИ ПРАКТИКИ „ПАРТНЬОРСТВО РОДИТЕЛИ – УЧИЛИЩЕ“

Мехмед Имамов, Калинка Гайтанинчева

2017 година
Книжка 9
ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКОТО УЧЕНИЕ НА Й. ФР. ХЕРБАРТ – ИСТОРИЯ И СЪВРЕМЕННОСТ

(По повод 240 г. от неговото рождение) Невена Филипова

Книжка 8
ЧЕТЯЩИЯТ СТУДЕНТ, ЧЕТЯЩОТО ДЕТЕ – ЕДНО МАЛКО ПРОЗОРЧЕ, ЕДНА ВЕЛИЧЕСТВЕНА ГЛЕДКА

Мариана Мандева, Боряна Туцева, Габриела Николова, Цветелина Ковачева

Книжка 7
ДИДАКТИЧЕСКИ КОМПЕТЕНТНОСТИ

Нели Митева, Наталия Витанова

Илияна Кунева

Книжка 6
Книжка 5
ИЗСЛЕДОВАТЕЛСКО ОБУЧЕНИЕ В АКАДЕМИЧНА СРЕДА

(Научно-теоретична рефлексия) Румяна Неминска

ПРИНОС В ПСИХОЛОГИЯТА НА ТВОРЧЕСТВОТО

(120 години от рождението на Лев Семьонович Виготски) Любен Десев

ЛЕВ СEМЬОНОВИЧ ВИГОТСКИ – ПСИХОЛОГ И НА ХХI ВЕК

(по случай 120 години от рождението му)

ИСКУССТВО В ЖИЗНИ ЛЮДЕЙ

Гульнар Омарова

НОВА И ПОЛЕЗНА КНИГА

Йонка Първанова

ПРИНОСЕН ТРУД КЪМ МЕТОДИКАТА НА ОБУЧЕНИЕТО ПО БЪЛГАРСКИ ЕЗИК И ЛИТЕРАТУРА В НАЧАЛНОТО УЧИЛИЩЕ

М. Мандева (2017). Методика на обучението по български език и литература – I – IV клас. Начално ограмотяване. В. Търново: УИ „Св. св. Кирил и Методий“, 120 стр.

ЕДНО ФУНДАМЕНТАЛНО ИНТЕГРАЛНО ИЗСЛЕДВАНЕ НА РОЛЯТА НА ОБРАЗОВАНИЕТО ЗА РАЗВИТИЕТО НА НООСФЕРНИЯ ИНТЕЛЕКТ

Марга Георгиева, Сава Гроздев. (2016). Морфодинамиката за развитието на ноосферния интелект. София: Изток-Запад, ISBN 978-619-152-869-1

Книжка 4
Книжка 3
СИСТЕМАТИЧНО ВЪВЕДЕНИЕ В ОБЩАТА И ПСИХОЛОГИЧЕСКАТА СИНЕРГЕТИКА

Любен Десев (2015). Синергетика. Въведение и речник. 777 термина. София: ИК „Екопрогрес“. 464 с. ISBN 978-954-2970-37-8

Книжка 2
ПРОБЛЕМИ И ПЕРСПЕКТИВИ В РАЗВИТИЕТО НА ХУДОЖЕСТВЕНОТО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ У НАС ПРЕЗ ПОГЛЕДА НА ДЕТСКИЯ И НАЧАЛНИЯ УЧИТЕЛ

Теодора Власева, Даниела Гирджева-Валачева, Мария Калоферова, Найден Младенов, Илияна Шотлекова

ЗАКЪСНЯЛО ПРИЗНАНИЕ

Доц. д-р Емилия Николова

Книжка 1
ФАКТОРИ ЗА УСПЕШНО ПРИЛАГАНЕ НА СМЕСЕНО ОБУЧЕНИЕ

Стоянка Георгиева-Лазарова Лъчезар Лазаров

ЗА СТОПЛЕНИТЕ ПЪТЕКИ КЪМ ЛИТЕРАТУРНОТО ПОЗНАНИЕ

Радев, Радослав. 2015. Технология на методите в обучението по литература. Варна: Славена, 247 с., ISBN 978-619-190-041-1

2016 година
Книжка 9
ИНТЕРАКТИВНИ ТЕХНИКИ ЗА ОВЛАДЯВАНЕ НА ЧЕТЕНЕТО В МУЛТИКУЛТУРНАТА КЛАСНА СТАЯ – ПЪРВИ КЛАС

ФОРМИРАНЕ НА РЕЧЕВА КУЛТУРА, В НАЧАЛНА УЧИЛИЩНА ВЪЗРАСТ, (АНАЛИЗ НА АНКЕТА С УЧИТЕЛИ

Кампания

на Института за български език – БАН, и вестник „Аз-буки“

Книжка 8
Книжка 7
IBM SPSS STATISTICS ПРЕЗ ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИЯ ПОГЛЕД НА ДОЦ. Д-Р ЗОРНИЦА ГАНЕВА

Зорница Ганева (2016). Да преоткрием статистиката с IBM SPSS Statistics. София: Елестра. 712 стр. ISBN 978-619-7292-01-5

НАЧАЛНОТО ОГРАМОТЯВАНЕ – „КЛЮЧ“ ЗА УСПЕШЕН ЖИВОТ В ПРОМЕНЯЩИЯ СЕ СВЯТ

Мариана Мандева, Диляна Гаджева (2016). Начално ограмотяване

ОТ „ЧУДНА И ДИВНА ДАСКАЛЕТИНКА“ ДО ПЕДАГОГИКА ЗА НАЦИОНАЛНО СЛУЧВАНЕ

Виолета Атанасова (2015) Петко Славейков за образованието. Шумен: Унивeрситетско издателство „Епископ Константин Преславски. 208 с. ISBN 978-619-201-051-5

Книжка 6
УЧИЛИЩЕ ЗА ЧЕТЕНЕ

Петя Георгиева

Кампания

на Института за български език – БАН, и в. „Аз Буки“

ДОШЛА ЛИ Е ИНСПЕКТОРЪТ?

Ванина Сумрова

ЩЕ ТЕ ЧАКАМ В/НА ЦЕНТЪРА

Илияна Гаравалова

ПРАВО В ДЕСЕТКАТА

Ивелина Стоянова

ПРОФ.Д.П.Н. СТОЯНКА ЖЕКОВА

Редколегия на сп. „Педагогика“

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
СИНЕРГЕТИКА – НОВО НАУЧНО ПОЗНАНИЕ

(Синергетика – въведение и речник, София: ИК Екопрогрес, 2015 г.)

Книжка 3
Книжка 2
НОВА ДИНАМИЧНА МОДИФИКАЦИЯ В ГРАНИЦИТЕ НА „АЗ-КОНЦЕПЦИЯТА“ НА МАТЕМАТИЧЕСКОТО МОДЕЛИРАНЕ

Марга Георгиева & Сава Гроздев. (2015). Морфодинамиката за развитието на ноосферния интелект, София: Марга Георгиева. 323 стр. ISBN 9786199052204

Книжка 1
IN MEMORIAM

На 10.12.2015 г. ни напусна нашият колега и приятел проф. д-р Иван Пет ков Иванов. Той беше уважаван учен и експерт в областта на педагогическите науки – автор на 10 монографии, 8 учебника, 10 учебни помагала, 6 студии и над 100 статии в специализирани периодич- ни издания и научни сборници; участник в 28 между- народни и национални проекта; председател и член на експертни групи към НАОА, член на редакционната ко- легия на сп. „Педагогика“. Проф. д-р Иван Иванов беше уважаван и оби

2015 година
Книжка 9
Книжка 8
РУСЕНСКИЯТ УНИВЕРСИТЕТ

Златоживка Здравкова

Книжка 7
ДИСКУСИЯТА В УРОКА ПО ЛИТЕРАТУРА

Огняна Георгиева-Тенева

Книжка 6
УЧИТЕЛЯТ ПРАВИ УЧИЛИЩЕТО

ЕЗИКОВАТА ГРАМОТНОСТ НА МАЛКИЯ УЧЕНИК – „КЛЮЧ“ ЗА ОТГОВОРЕН И УСПЕШЕН ЖИВОТ В ПРОМЕНЯЩИЯ СЕ СВЯТ

ГОТОВНОСТ ЗА ОГРАМОТЯВАНЕ

Екатерина Чернева

Книжка 5
Книжка 4
Книжка 3
ВЗАИМОДЕЙСТВИЕ МЕЖДУ ИСТОРИЯ, АКАДЕМИЗЪМ И РЕАЛНИ ПРАКТИКИ В СОЦИАЛНОПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКАТА ДЕЙНОСТ

Академични полета на социалната педагогика, съставител: проф. д.п.н. Клавдия Сапунджиева, научна редакция: проф. дпн Клавдия Сапунджиева, проф. д-р Нели Бояджиева, гл. ас. д-р Марина Пиронкова,

НОВА КНИГА

Клавдия Сапунджиева

Книжка 2
ПРОБЛЕМИ НА СОЦИАЛНАТА АДАПТАЦИЯ НА ПЪТУВАЩИ УЧЕНИЦИ ОТ МАЛКИ НАСЕЛЕНИ МЕСТА1)

Траян Попкочев, Бонка Гергинова, Тереза Карамангалова

Турнир по канадска борба [Arm Wrestling Competition] / Д. Евтимова,

Д. Евтимова, Е. Павлова, И. Радославова и Б. Иванов

Книжка 1
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE: THEORY AND REALITY

Inna Leonidovna Fedotenko

ОТЗИВ ЗА КНИГАТА „ОБРАЗОВАТЕЛЕН ДИЗАЙН (КОНЦЕПТУАЛНИ ОСНОВАНИЯ И ПРАКТИЧЕСКИ РЕШЕНИЯ)“

Димова, Д. (2013). Образователен дизайн (концептуални основания

2014 година
Книжка 9
„СОФИЯ – УЧЕЩ СЕ ГРАД“ – МОБИЛЕН СЕМИНАР В ПОДКРЕПА НА НЕФОРМАЛНОТО УЧЕНЕ И ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ В ОБЩНОСТТА

ПЕТЪР ДЪНОВ (БЕИНСÀ ДУНÒ Е И БЕЛЕЖИТ, ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИ МИСЛИТЕЛ-ХУМАНИСТ, (ПО ПОВОД НА 0-ГОДИШНИНАТА ОТ РОЖДЕНИЕТО, И 70 ГОДИНИ ОТ КОНЧИНАТА МУ

НА УЧИЛИЩЕ – С УСМИВКА!

Снежана Якимова

НА УЧИЛИЩЕ – С УСМИВКА!

Снежана Якимова

УЧИТЕЛЯТ – ЕТАЛОН ЗА ФОРМИРАНЕ НА ДЕТСКАТА ЛИЧНОСТ

Катя Коруджийска, Янка Маринкова

Книжка 8
Книжка 7
ЗАЕДНО МОЖЕМ ПОВЕЧЕ

Диана Смиленова

Книжка 6
УСПЕШНИЯТ УЧИТЕЛ – МЕЖДУ ПРОФЕСИОНАЛНАТА НОРМА И СТРАСТТА ДА ПРЕПОДАВАШ

Проф. д-р Ангел Петров е преподавател по методика на обучението по български език в СУ „Св. Климент Охридски“. Ръководител е на най- старата катедра по методика на филологически- те дисциплини в страната – Катедрата по ме-

Книжка 5
ВЪЗГЛЕДИТЕ НА ЖАН-ЖАК РУСО И ЛЮБЕН КАРАВЕЛОВ ЗА ВЪЗПИТАНИЕТО

Посвещава се на 180-ата годишнина от рождението на Любен Каравелов (1834 – 1879) Виолета Атанасова

LE PROJET PÉDAGOGIQUE, SOURCE DE MOTIVATION DANS L’ENSEIGNEMENT ET L’APPRENTISSAGE DU FLE

THE EDUCATIONAL PROJECT, MEANS OF MOTIVATION IN TEACHING AND LEARNING FLE

LA PÉDAGOGIE DU PROJET ET LA MOTIVATION DES ÉLÈVES POUR L’APPRENTISSAGE DU FRANÇAIS

PROJECT PEDAGOGY AND PUPILS’ MOTIVATION IN LEARNING FRENCH

Книжка 4
КАЖДЫЙ ДЛЯ МЕНЯ УЧИТЕЛЬ

Ш.А.Амонашвили

Книжка 3
АНТОАНЕТА ЙОВЧЕВА (1952 – 2014)

След трудна борба с тежката болест ни напусна един добър и мил човек, една светла личност – Анто- анета Йовчева, нашата обичана колежка Тони. Нейните колеги и приятели, многобройните автори и сътрудници на сп. „Начално образование“ и на сп. „Педагогика“ ще запазят завинаги спомена за нейната приветлива усмивка, за нейната отзивчивост и преда- ност към работата, за нейната широка култура и стре- меж към познание, към развитие. Родена на 20 март 1952 г. в София в интелигентно се- мей

Книжка 2
ПОСТМОДЕРНИЗЪМ И ВЪЗПИТАНИЕ

Клавдия Сапунджиева

ДЕТСКИ УНИВЕРСИТЕТИ

Боряна Иванова

ПРОФ. Д-Р ЕЛКА ПЕТРОВА

Има личности, в сиянието на които се оглеж- дат цяла плеада последователи, възпитаници, колеги; има личности, без които животът става по беден, дните по-еднообразни, защото в сър- цето остава празно място. Такава личност е професор, доктор на педа- гогическите науки Елка Петрова – най–големият ерудит в областта на предучилищното възпита - ние, учен с международно значение. Дълги години ще свеждаме глави пред нейна- та обаятелна личност, с искрена признателност ще си спомняме свидните

МЕЖДУНАРОДНЫЙ ЦЕНТР ГУМАННОЙ ПЕДАГОГИКИ

Международният център „Хуманна педагогика“ организира XIII педаго- гически четения в периода 20 – 23.03.2014 г. в гр.Тбилиси, Грузия. Форумът се организира със съдействието на грузинското правителство. „Учителят“ е темата, която ще обедини участниците: учители, експерти, родители, универ- ситетски преподаватели, представители на педагогическата общност от мно- го страни, за да се осъществи дискусия за мисията на съвременния учител в съвременния образователен контекст. Ръководството на

Книжка 1
ОСНОВНИ ХАРАКТЕРИСТИКИ НА МОБИЛНОТО ОБУЧЕНИЕ

Стоянка Георгиева-Лазарова Лъчезар Лазаров

2013 година
Книжка 9
УЧИТЕЛИ ВЪЗРОЖДЕНЦИ В ТЪРНОВО

Венка Кутева-Цветкова

Книжка 8
ДИМИТЪР ДОНЧЕВ – С ВЪЗХИТА ЗА БЪЛГАРСКИЯ УЧИТЕЛ

100 ГОДИНИ ОТ РОЖДЕНИЕТО НА ДИМИТЪР ЕВСТАТИЕВ ДОНЧЕВ (5.10.1913 – 15.02.1997)

Книжка 7
„СЛЪНЦЕТО“ НА ВЪЗПИТАТЕЛНАТА СИСТЕМА В ТВУ – РАКИТОВО

85 ГОДИНИ ОТ РОЖДЕНИЕТО НА АНГЕЛ УЗУНОВ (1928 – 1999)

ЦЕННОСТИ И ДУХОВНО-НРАВСТВЕНО РАЗВИТИЕ НА МАЛКИЯ УЧЕНИК

Марияна Ешкенази, Гергана Фиданова, Марияна Вишева, Цветанка Годжилова

МАЛКИЯТ УЧЕНИК ЧЕТЕ

Марияна Механджиева Венета Велева

С БАБА И ДЯДО В КЛАС

Цветелин Горанов, Таня Илиева, Цветанка Берова, Нели Иванова, Борка Бончева

РОД РОДА НЕ ХРАНИ, НО ТЕЖКО МУ, КОЙТО ГО НЯМА!

Диляна Вачкова Евелина Димитрова

ДА ПОМОГНЕМ НА ДЕЦАТА ДА ОТВОРЯТ СЪРЦАТА СИ

Иванка Дебелушина Нина Маврикова

ДОБРОТО Е У ВСЕКИ

Мария Наскова

ОТЛИЧЕН ПЕДАГОГ, ПСИХОЛОГ И ПСИХОТЕРАПЕВТ

ДОЦ. СВЕТОСЛАВ СТАМЕНОВ (1939 – 2013)

Книжка 6
ТЕОРЕТИКО-ПРИЛОЖНИ ПРОБЛЕМИ НА КОНСТРУИРАНЕТО НА ТЕСТ ЗА НАЦИОНАЛНО ВЪНШНО ОЦЕНЯВАНЕ ПО „ЧОВЕКЪТ И ОБЩЕСТВОТО“ ЗА 4. КЛАС (2013)

Ваня Петрова, Цонка Каснакова, Мариан Делчев Жана Минчева Радостина Стоянова, Рада Димитрова Мария Темникова

MEDIA IN PRESCHOOL AGE OF CHILD’S LIFE

Sonja Petrovska Jadranka Bocvarova

Книжка 5
ШАЛВА АЛЕКСАНДРОВИЧ АМОНАШВИЛИ – УЧИТЕЛ ОТ БЪДЕЩЕТО

В сложното битие на науката и метамор- фозите на социалната реалност, неотменими и общовалидни остават само най-стойностни- те постижения и безспорни истини, които не само маркират и остойностяват територията на човешко познание, но извисяват самия чо- век, поддържат неговата вяра в доброто, под- хранват чувството му за собствена значимост, укрепват неговия дух. Приемайки извечните послания на класи- ческата философско-педагогическа мъдрост и дълбоко обвързан с педагогическата р

МАНИФЕСТ ГУМАННОЙ ПЕДАГОГИКИ

Преамбула 25 лет тому назад группа учителей новаторов провозгласила манифест „Пе- дагогика сотрудничества“ (Переделкино, 1986 год). В последующие годы были опубликованы отчеты встреч учителей новаторов, в которых рассматри- вались разные аспекты педагогики сотрудничества: „Демократизация лично- сти“ (Цинандали, Телавский район, Грузия, 1987 год), „Методика обновления“ (Москва, 1988 год), „Войдем в новую школу“ (Краснодарский край, 1988 год). Идеи педагогики сотрудничества воодушевленно

ПОРТФОЛИОТО НА УЧЕНИКА КАТО ПРОЦЕС НА САМОПОЗНАНИЕ

Радка Топалска Емилия Вълкова, Албена Атанасова

ДОПИРНИ СВЕТОВЕ

Албена Димитрова Стилияна Гронева

ПРЕДИ ГОДИНА И СЕГА

Веселка Аршинкова

Книжка 4
СВЕЩЕНИК ГЕОРГИ МАРИНОВ ПОЛУГАНОВ – ОСНОВАТЕЛЯТ НА УЧИЛИЩЕТО И ПЪРВИЯТ УЧИТЕЛ В ПОЛИКРАЙЩЕ

Георги Георгиев Трифонка Попниколова Марияна Георгиева–Гроссе

ЕВРОПЕЙСКИ ПРИКАЗКИ

Светла Попова

Книжка 3
ДА ОПАЗИМ ДЕТСКОТО ЗДРАВЕ!

Мая Топалова, Симона Пейчева

КАК ДА ОТГЛЕДАМЕ МАЛЪК ПРИРОДОЛЮБИТЕЛ?

Мадлена Николова Ани Цветкова

Книжка 2
Книжка 1
ИЗКУСТВОТО ЗА ПРЕВЕНЦИЯ НА АГРЕСИВНОТО ПОВЕДЕНИЕ НА ДЕЦАТА

Евгения Миланова Виолета Николова Величка Радева

ПРИЯТЕЛСТВОТО В ЖИВОТА НА ДЕТЕТО

Даниела Димитрова Красимира Василева

ПРЕДАЙ НАТАТЪК

Вилдан Мехмедова

ЗАЕДНО ДА БЪДЕМ ДОБРИ

(ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКА СИТУАЦИЯ В ПОДГОТВИТЕЛНА ГРУПА)

ПРОФ. ДПН EЛКА ПЕТРОВА EДНА НЕЗАЛИЧИМА СЛЕДА В БЪЛГАРСКОТО ПРЕДУЧИЛИЩНО ОБРАЗОВАНИЕ (1919 – 2012)

Почина проф. дпн Елка Петрова (20.ХІІ.2012 г.) – на- шата любима учителка по изкуството да се живее пъл- ноценно и професионално, създателката на науката за предучилищното възпитание на българските деца, пре- красната жена и велика майка, Неповторима, единствена, съвършена – това е нашата Елка: Примерът за всички нас – хилядите нейни студенти и последователи ! Елка Петрова винаги е първа, винаги е оригинална и авангардна; през 1950–1952 г. поставя началото на Висшия мето

2012 година
Книжка 9
ПЕДАГОГЪТ – РИЦАР НА ДЕТСТВОТО

Януш Корчак бе написал, че животът на великите хора е като легендите: труден, но красив. И се оказва пророчески прав, сякаш е писал за себе си! Наследник на семейство с богата духовна култура и традиции, останал отрано без баща, той не просто се справя с несгодите на сирачеството, но развива у себе си три могъщи извора на живот: любов към свободата и справедливостта, страст към знанието и творчеството, отдаденост на децата и тяхното щастие. Лекарят Корчак лекува децата и душите им. Безплатн

ЯНУШ КОРЧАК – ВЕЛИК ХУМАНИСТ И ПЕДАГОГ

„Със сила и мощ поведох своя живот, който беше привидно неподреден, самотен и чужд. За син избрах идеята да служа на детето и неговото дело. Привидно загубих.“ Бе лекар, писател, мислител. Бе философ, учен, моралист. Издател. Възпи- тател и педагог. Бе герой. Бе скромен. Във всяка от тези области той има изключителни постижения. В течение на по- вече от четиридесет години работи като педагог и писател. Четиридесет години безкористно служене на слабите и беззащитните. Създава съвременна кон

ЕВОЛЮЦИЯ НА ПРАВАТА НА ДЕТЕТО

„Детето има право на сериозно отношение към проблемите му, на справедливото им решаване.“

THE KORCZAK’S RIGHT TO SOCIAL PARTICIPATION OF CHILDREN THE CITIZENSHIP OF CHILDREN

A speech by Marek Michalak, the Ombudsman for Children, given during the seminar„The Polish-Israeli pioneer in the fi eld of human rights, Janusz Korczak (1879–1942) and today’s Convention on Children’s Rights as the part of the international law“, Geneva, the 6 of June 2009

ЗА ДЕТЕТО, ДЕТСТВОТО ИЛИ НАУКА ЗА НЕГО?

В памет на Януш Корчак – по повод 70 г. от неговата смърт и 100 г. от създаването на „Дом за сираци“ във Варшава Албена Чавдарова

Книжка 8
CHANGES IN UNIVERSITY TEACHING – THE ROAD FROM KNOWLEDGE TO COMPETENCIES

Slađana Anđelković Zorica Stanisavljević Petrović

ДОСТОЕН ЖИВОТ, ОТДАДЕН НА ПРОСВЕЩЕНИЕТО… ПРОФ. СТОЙКА ЗДРАВКОВА – ЕДИН СЪВРЕМЕНЕН БУДИТЕЛ НА 70 ГОДИНИ

Неуморна и взискателна! Енергична и всеотдай- на! Работохолик и перфекционист! Това е проф. д-р Стойка Здравкова! Не е за вярване, че в началото на ноември 2012 година навърши 70 години. И не е слу- чайно това, че тази светла дата е непосредствено бли- зо до Деня на будителите. А това, че проф . Здравкова е съвременен български будител, е толкова безспорно и видимо! 70–годишнината ù е един чудесен повод ретрос- пективно да си припомним и проследим най-значи-

Книжка 7
ОЧАКВАНА И ПОЛЕЗНА

Емилия Василева

Книжка 6
Книжка 5
ЦЕННО ПОМАГАЛО ЗА ПСИХОЛОЗИ И ПЕДАГОЗИ (Надежден инструмент за диагностициране смисъла на живота)

Любен Десев Минчев, Борис. Тест на Дж. Крумбъг и Л. Махолик за смисъл в живота. Българска версия. Варна, ВСУ „Черноризец Храбър“,

ГЕОРГИ MАВРОВ ЖИВОТ, ОТДАДЕН НА НАУКАТА И ОБРАЗОВАНИЕТО

Така най-общо, но и най-точно можем да охарак- теризираме дейността на ст. н. с. д-р Георги Петков Мавров. Той ни напусна неочаквано в края на април т.г. И до последния си ден не преставаше да се вълнува от проблемите на образованието. Споделяше инте- ресни мисли относно предстоящото приемане на За- кона за образованието. Пестелив на думи, но щедър на дела – това ясно проличава от неговата богата би- ография.

Книжка 4
ОЩЕ ЕДНА ИДЕЯ

Галина Стоянова

Книжка 3
С ИНОВАТИВЕН ПОГЛЕД КЪМ ЛИЧНОСТТА НА ДЕТЕТО

Маргарита Абрашева Любимка Габрова

БИЗНЕС ОБУЧЕНИЕ В ДЕТСКАТА ГРАДИНА

Красимира Костова Петя Драгоданова

ДЕТСКАТА БЕЗОПАСНОСТ

Любимка Габрова

БАБА ПРИКАЗКИ РАЗКАЗВА... (МИКС ОТ ПРИКАЗКИ)

Кева Захариева, Мария Мичева

Книжка 2
ДЕТЕ ПЪТУВА В АВТОМОБИЛА

Красимира Михайлова

ПРОТИВОПОСТАВЯНЕ

Пюрвя Ердниев, Б. Ердниев

ЗДРАВКА НОВАКОВА – ПРЕПОДАВАТЕЛ И ТВОРЕЦ

Седемдесетгодишният юбилей е вълнуващ повод да проследим трудния, богат и съдържателен професионално-творчески път на доц. д-р Здравка Новакова, да под- чертаем нейната важна роля за утвърждаване на дидактика на математиката като

IN MEMORIAM Иван Марев

Напусна ни проф. Иван Марев – философ, педагог, демократ, родолюбец. В далечната 1975 г., зареден с енергия, пълен с идеи, той създаде в Техническия

Книжка 1
ДЕЛЕГИРАНЕ НА ПРАВА ЧРЕЗ КОМИСИИТЕ В ДЕТСКАТА ГРАДИНА

Маргарита Абрашева Политиката, наречена управление на качеството, не е самоцел, нито поредна обра- зователна „мода“. Тя е практически необходима за поддържане от директора на учеб- ното заведение на един привлекателен образ в условията на конкуренция на пазара на учебни заведения. Това се отнася най-вече за детските градини. Политиката на упра- вление на качеството съдържа недостатъчно използван ресурс, включително за спечел- ване и запазване доверието на потребителя – родителите на децата,

ИНОВАЦИОННИ И ИНТЕРАКТИВНИ МЕТОДИ В КВАЛИФИКАЦИОННАТА ДЕЙНОСТ НА ПЕДАГОГИЧЕСКИЯ КОЛЕКТИВ

Стоилка Ташева, Севда Лукайчева Развиващото се с динамични темпове общество в днешно време налага необ- ходимостта от иновационни промени в областта на образованието. И в предучи- лищната педагогика все по-често се търсят алтернативни педагогически техноло- гии както за възпитанието и обучението на децата, така и при провеждането на квалификационната дейност на самите педагози. Използването на интерактивните методи дава възможност да се възлагат за- дачи, които предполагат съвместна работа,

ТОВА ТРЯБВА ДА ГО ЗНАЕ ВСЯКО ДЕТЕ

Татяна Атанасова, Иванка Пампова

НА УЛИЦАТА Е ОПАСНО

Таня Янчева, Зоя Кацарова